26 ms·
What I don't get about these ideas is that isn't the factor "how much do you need to be in the office?" If you don't need to be in the office, why not just keep
by godelski 6y ago
What I don't get about these ideas is that isn't the factor "how much do you need to be in the office?" If you don't need to be in the office, why not just keep salaries the same and then you select from a larger pool of candidates (this should give you a pretty good pick, but you're still limited by when waking hours overlap).
If you only need to be in the office once a month, dock a little as now you have to cover travel and lodging.
It really seems like the factor of pay should be based on how important physical presence is, not on where the person is. Because otherwise I don't see it as a rational thing for a headquarters to be in SF and an employee in Arizona to get paid less than an employee in NYC. There's more advantages for the company for having your employee(your average programmer, at least) be in AZ rather than NYC. You need them in the office? A whole lot easier/cheaper to get that AZ employee there.
- UncleMeat 6y ago> why not just keep salaries the same and then you select from a larger pool of candidates (this should give you a pretty good pick, but you're still limited by when waking hours overlap). Because you make less profit if you pay the outrageously high SF salaries. Bay Area salaries are incredibly high because there is outrageous competition for the top engineers and there are a lot of rich companies local to the region who can afford high salaries. They aren't able to hire a bay area engineer at 2/3 pay because that hire can go somewhere else. If you are one of the early ones to the remote-game then you aren't competing with other bay area companies for an engineer in Tulsa. You are competing with local Tulsa businesses, which don't tend to make the gazillions in profit or VC money needed to afford to pay engineers 300k+. So you don't lose as many candidates when you say now you are paying 150k. So you make more money. Over time this difference could even out as more and more companies become remote-friendly or remote-first and there are no more local job markets. But this isn't going to end with bay area salaries for the whole world outside of a very very small number of companies and very top performers who can command high pay.
- godelski 6y agoHow does this address a office in SF and a remote worker in NYC making more than a remote worker in Phoenix? Both workers are remote. How does the NYC worker provide ~2x utility to the company compared to the AZ worker (remember, both are remote).
- Spivak 6y agoThey don’t! Which is why in this new remote world the applicant in Phoenix has the advantage because they’re able to accept a lower salary because of CoL. None of this makes any god damn sense in regards to adjusting the pay of people that move but it doesn’t matter in the long run because such practices are still governed by market forces. Facebook can try and predict what someone is willing to accept based on their location and renegotiate based on their available options but it’s not infinite leverage.
- UncleMeat 6y agoPeople aren't paid by their utility (if that were true, employees at highly profitable companies would be paid a lot more). They are paid the lowest amount that either the market (or other forces - like unions) will bear. A remote worker in Phoenix doesn't have as many options as a remote worker in NYC when it comes to switching jobs a getting a high salary. So the company pays the NYC dev more since they need to pay more in order to retain that person. I'm absolutely certain that there are some 10x engineers in Bangalore that are getting paid peanuts because they can be exploited and don't have as many options. That's the nature of capitalism and why many see it as an extractive system.
- war1025 6y ago> in Bangalore that are getting paid peanuts because they can be exploited The thing about Cost of Living is that poor schmuck in Banagalore may well be living like a king off those wages compared to his other options. I made a pittance in west coast tech terms, but here in Iowa that means I own my house outright, I have a wife that doesn't need to work, and I have three kids. From what I read on here that is a pipe dream for many of the same west coast tech people. I'll take Iowa.
- 6y ago
- eanzenberg 6y agoWhy is it a surprise? The moment the employee is willing to hire remotely the employer is competing against people willing to make half or less, since they don’t care to live where you decide to live. Hilarious right? Same happens when minimum wage goes up. Imagine it goes up to a livable $40/hr. Now these high school kids are competing with people with college degrees for the same job.
- godelski 6y agoI'm not sure this makes sense. Did I not include these people? Wage as a function of distance, right? I didn't say that everyone gets paid the same. And is it not more advantageous for the employer to be able to select from a larger pool of candidates? > Imagine it goes up to a livable $40/hr. Now these high school kids are competing with people with college degrees for the same job. Do they? This doesn't mean that every job that pays under $40/hr (which is pretty high! You must be living in the Bay) becomes $40/hr and jobs higher do not go up as well. But rather now those companies have to compete (you can compete in ways more than wage, especially if it is $40/hr!). High school kids may have to compete with people with college degrees for things like McDonalds, but now an engineering firm like Boeing (who pays less than $40/hr for starting salaries in most locations) has to compete with McDonalds. The competition doesn't work only in one direction. Of course, I'm sure that there's a upperbound to how well this works though, and I wouldn't be surprised if it was under $80k/yr
- jsjohnst 6y ago> Imagine it goes up to a livable $40/hr. $40/hr is a high salary for many parts of the US, so I assume your “livable” comment is relative to the Bay Area?
- taneq 6y ago> Imagine it goes up to a livable $40/hr. Now these high school kids are competing with people with college degrees for the same job. A lot of these predictions seem based on assuming nothing else changes when the minimum wage changes. Realistically you're not going to have college grads applying for highschool-kid jobs, you're going to see college grad jobs paying more.
- 6y ago