3 ms·
What you say here is certainly true. Many stories are oversimplified, and stories are a good way to fool ourselves. However, I'd like to push back gently on th
by logicprog 6y ago
What you say here is certainly true. Many stories are oversimplified, and stories are a good way to fool ourselves.
However, I'd like to push back gently on the idea that we should never use narratives.
It is true that _traditional story structures_ don't necessarily reflect the real structure of historical experience/occurence, but they _can_ fit, too. It really depends on the occurence. And more importantly, stories can be infinitely granular and complex (just read _War and Peace_ or _In Search of Lost Time_, for example), complex and granular enough to capture actual historical experience without distortion.
As for people not describing their lives as a mess, that's because a mess has no structure - whereas a journey or a battle has a structure; life does not necessarily have structure, sure, but those people who choose to describe their lives in structured ways do so because they are _giving_ it structure. If someone's life is structured (by them) as a pursuit of some goal or state, where everything that happens either helps that, hinders that, or acts as a side-quest, then they may well describe it as a journey. A fractally complex journey, but a journey nonetheless.
- jadbox 6y ago> just read _War and Peace_ or _In Search of Lost Time_, for example These are excellent well-contrasting examples, well put. > A fractally complex journey, but a journey nonetheless. Do you write frequently? This is one of my favorite comments on HN in terms of style and etiquette.
- logicprog 6y agoThank you for your kind words, you really made my day! I do in fact write quite often: usually around ten thousand words a week, although most of it isn't exactly amazing. Also yes, I thought ISoLT and W&P contrasted nicely.