3 ms·
I don't get why a full year's worth of background radiation is always compared to an acute 5-sec (or less) exposure from an x-ray machine. If the background ra
by hammock 6y ago
I don't get why a full year's worth of background radiation is always compared to an acute 5-sec (or less) exposure from an x-ray machine.
If the background rate is 50msv/year, and a machine doses that much (50msv) in 5 seconds, that's 6.3 MILLION TIMES greater than the background dose.
- sizzle 6y agoThis is an excellent point, does an acute dose of radiation in a short timespan cause more cellular damage than long-term exposure?
- acidburnNSA 6y agoAbsolutely yes. But acute low-dose below 100,000 μSv has never been shown to cause or not cause harm.
- acidburnNSA 6y agoUsing uniform units, 0.25 μSv acute dose is what the manufacturers claim for these devices. Annual average background from all sources in US (including these) 6,000 μSv/yr. So you need a scan every 21 minutes for a year to roughly double your annual dose. In some parts of the world, the natural background rate is higher. Like 50,000 μSv/yr. Cancers or other harm have never been shown to occur (or not occur) below acute or annual doses of about 100,000 μSv. So you need 400,000 of these scans (at the manufactuer-claimed dose of μSv) to reach a dose that is thought to have an above-zero increase cancer risk.
- lvs 6y agoYou're not grasping the biology. Damage repair mechanisms have a capacity limit that itself varies with exposure. In particular it's been shown that acute dosage timing of multiple exposures is different than continuous exposure with the same integrated dose.
- acidburnNSA 6y agoI will strengthen my statement. Acute doses below 100 mSv have never been conclusively shown to cause or not cause harm or benefit. Certainly annual doses at that level also have not. The LD50/30 acute dose of radiation is 4,000 mSv. See chart I linked above. Certainly acute high doses are worse than the same dose spread over years or decades. I learned that in nuclear engineering school 20 years ago. Please don't assume I'm not grasping it.
- godelski 6y ago> I don't get why a full year's worth of background radiation is always compared to an acute 5-sec (or less) exposure from an x-ray machine. Usually because we don't have as much data on acute exposures. The best are from Chernobyl and the atomic bombs (tests and weapons). The issue with these is that we're talking about dosages that are MUCH higher. You'll also find plenty of studies with pilots (and even mechanics), medical staff, and dentists but if you read into the reports you'll see that there are a lot of factors involved that make it difficult to call radiation the culprit, specifically because these groups are exposed to a lot of other known carcinogens and are likely to be tested more frequently (pilots get frequent medicals and doctors are.... well... you know... doctors). So pretty much no matter what you do, there aren't great comparisons and noway to completely isolate just radiation. Edit: it is hard to get this data because it is unethical to just expose people to radiation and see at what levels they die at. Plus, such a study would take decades