3 ms·
> Most book clubs are doing it wrong... You have one meeting per book.... The problem is that there’s no time to cash in on anyone else’s insights. > My book c
by crazygringo 6y ago
> Most book clubs are doing it wrong... You have one meeting per book.... The problem is that there’s no time to cash in on anyone else’s insights.
> My book club started four years ago to read Infinite Jest.
Well SHEESH -- most book clubs aren't trying to read 1,079 page long books. Of course you're going to need to break that up.
But the idea that anyone else is doing it "wrong" is both nonsensical and incredibly arrogant. Book clubs are usually concerned with much shorter books that are more easily accessible, where of course you can understand each others' insights afterwards.
And for me, the goal isn't just (or even primarily) to understand the book better or "cash in", as it is more to understand your friends better and enjoy time together. Even if you haven't read the book at all, you can go to hear what they have to say and discuss the topics raised generally.
(If your goal is primarily to understand the book better, you'll probably get a lot more out of reading reviews, analysis, etc. online that meeting with friends, unless your friends happen to be English professors, writers for the New Yorker, etc.)
- wrsh07 6y agoYeah this is written from a pretty narrow perspective Relevant questions: what bookclubs was the author familiar with? and what books were they reading? The bookclubs I'm familiar with are all run by and for the sake of their members, and if the goal is either encourage regular reading or just social, they'll checkpoint at the same pace regardless of the book (eg every 2-4 weeks) and decide how much to read depending... on the book? The idea that most bookclubs wouldn't do this seems very bizarre to me, and I just can't imagine the sampling the author had done prior to this post