3 ms·
> My general understanding is that most people do take peer review to be such a filter. If they do, then they're wrong, since peer review explicitly disclaims
by pdonis 6y ago
> My general understanding is that most people do take peer review to be such a filter.
If they do, then they're wrong, since peer review explicitly disclaims any indication that a paper is correct or should be believed. And this is supported by the fact that a large fraction of peer-reviewed papers turn out to be wrong.
> I'm also someone solving a real serious scientific problem and I'm dependent on trusting that people with PhD's who answer questions of mine about cell biology or whatever can be trusted because, unlike me, they had the capacity to pursue a PhD.
It depends on what questions you're asking them and what their basis is for their answers. If their basis is solid experimental knowledge of whatever aspect of cell biology you're asking about, then yes, their answers are probably trustworthy. If their basis is speculation about something we don't have much experimental knowledge of, then no, their answers are probably not trustworthy. In either case, you're not going to find that out by looking at whether what they're saying has been peer reviewed. You're going to find out by asking them how they know the things they're telling you and critically evaluating their answers.
> I'm too busy solving a scientific problem
> I sort of have "infinite time"
You can't be "too busy" if you have "infinite time". It's just a question of how you choose to employ your time. It would seem to me to be a better idea to employ it in becoming an expert yourself, so you can critically evaluate what other experts are saying, than to look for a shortcut filter, whether it's peer review or anything else. Asking other experts questions can certainly help with that; but it might be helpful to view that not as looking for answers from them, but as using what they say to help you build your own expertise.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoIt's just a question of how you choose to employ your time. I'm going to try one last time to clarify what I meant and then I am done here because this is going all kinds of weird places I never expected. I'm medically handicapped. I have a very serious and deadly condition and failing to die of it takes all my time. That fact has prevented me from finishing my BS in Environmental Resource Management, a major chosen to further my career goals. My interest in and need for information on cell biology is driven by the fact that I was diagnosed somewhat late in life with a very serious genetic disorder. So I wouldn't be interested in pursuing such knowledge if I weren't medically handicapped. I would be a city planner or something, like I wanted to be. The fact that my medical condition has stomped my life into the ground and made me unemployable is why I have a lot of time on my hands and I choose to prioritize learning knowledge pertinent to addressing my health issues under circumstances where, no, it's simply not possible for me to do something like pursue a PhD in biology. And I am getting results, so your opinions about how I should spend my time aside, I'm fairly satisfied with the choices I am making (all things considered), though I wish I didn't have this personal challenge. I wish I were healthy and life had gone differently. But it didn't.
- pdonis 6y agoI'm very sorry about your condition and that you're having to go through all you are going through. > it's simply not possible for me to do something like pursue a PhD in biology Becoming an expert is not the same as getting a credential. It's perfectly possible to become an expert in whatever particular condition you personally have, without getting a PhD in biology, or indeed any relevant degree. Indeed, since you say you are getting results, I suspect you are becoming an expert in your particular condition, whether you planned to or not. My wife has a chronic illness and she has been forced to become an expert in it (with no relevant degrees at all) even though she would much rather have spent the time on other things. > I am getting results I'm glad you are; that's the most important thing.