3 ms·
Feedback week seems like a way to introduce a tremendous amount of politics to the workplace. "Feedback week" is not an outcome I would leave to chance unless
by MattGaiser 6y ago
Feedback week seems like a way to introduce a tremendous amount of politics to the workplace.
"Feedback week" is not an outcome I would leave to chance unless I trusted management to an extraordinary degree. Getting good feedback would become my priority for the week before and I would be forming partnerships with people to play up certain aspects, especially if management (the people who decide my paychecks) are going to be hearing it. Why would I do all this? It is very hard to shake a negative impression, so preventing one is imperative.
Feedback week tells me to spend the week before not asking for help which may be hard to provide, investing in colleague lunches, sending them job postings and encouraging them to seek a promotion, withholding cool productivity improvements until just before feedback week (I have this cool new automation script), and planning my feedback with close team members.
That seems like a worse outcome than having me actually doing work.
- jacques_chester 6y ago> "Feedback week" is not an outcome I would leave to chance unless I trusted management to an extraordinary degree. I worked for the same company as Denise and yes, I had that kind of trust in my management. I have received at times quite blunt feedback, but it has never to my knowledge put me at threat of losing my job. I have at other times been left feeling cynical, hurt or angry, but expressing those feelings has never put me at threat of losing my job. It's doable. It's just hard and takes a lot of time, a lot of patience and willingness to improve in small steps.
- z6 6y agoI would say losing your job is at the extreme end. There are many ways it could have impacted you without you even knowing. Obvious ones are missing out on promotions, getting a lower raise, bonus, etc. I think it's incredibly naive to think there would be no impact.
- jacques_chester 6y agoI was involved in student politics and then grownup politics, so I feel qualified to exercise all due cynicism about people's motivations. Once I got over literally every other professional experience I'd ever had, Pivotal was the real deal.
- MattGaiser 6y ago> I had that kind of trust in my management. That's impressive. Would you consider yourself the trusting type?
- jacques_chester 6y agoIt depends on the situation.
- iateanapple 6y ago> Getting good feedback would become my priority for the week before It should be your primary job all the time in feedback based organizations.
- MattGaiser 6y agoIf it is peer feedback I then spend a ton of time doing things not related to my actual job. If it is management feedback, isn't that just most jobs?
- donw 6y ago> If it is peer feedback I then spend a ton of time doing things not related to my actual job. Like what? Also, what is your actual job?
- MattGaiser 6y agoI am a developer. When I have had peer reviews within organizations (my current one does not do this), I usually convince other team members to let me write my own to save them the time or ask them to help me craft my review of them (and they usually reciprocate). Most of the time they let me write both and just approve their own. I end up spending my time crafting my own narrative instead of working as well as giving them a convincing one in exchange.
- ncphillips 6y agoThe article states that teams with high psychological safety have success with feedback weeks, it does not say that feedback week results in high psychological safety.
- majormajor 6y agoThere's a high level of distrust in this comment, both of peers and of managers, which I think misses an underlying thing: teams without this level of distrust of each other and of management have a lot of advantages. So if you're a manager: do your damnedest to build trust. If you don't have that trust, it will be hard to pull off any of these activities. Even around things like spreading work and knowledge around - distrust is how you get people hoarding knowledge for perceived job security; or bitterness about being asked to do something they aren't the best at (feeling like you're setting them up to fail instead of trying to up their skills).
- g051051 6y agoI just don't trust people in general...it has nothing to do with the team. I've been stabbed in the back too many times for trusting people to do the right thing.
- renewiltord 6y agoHopefully, it is made clear to you that the team operates as a high-trust cooperative and you can self-select out of that environment since you find it undesirable. You and this style of team are incompatible.
- pixelbash 6y agoThis makes little sense in context. Whether or not someone finds something desirable doesn't matter if their experience is that it doesn't happen in practise. It's hard to unlearn painful lessons in trust.