3 ms·
It's fascinating to see people having such strong moral intuitions that restaurant people deserve to get paid for their work, while food delivery people do not.
by BurningFrog 6y ago
It's fascinating to see people having such strong moral intuitions that restaurant people deserve to get paid for their work, while food delivery people do not.
- thescriptkiddie 6y agoGrubHub charges a 15-30% fee, of which only 10% goes to the delivery person. On average the app owners are making twice as much as the person who does all of the actual work.
- BurningFrog 6y agoBy "food delivery people" I mean the entire company, not just the person in the car. So it's the app developers and management that don't deserve to get paid? Despite the large fees, these companies are all losing tons of money. So it's not like anyone is getting rich by overcharging restaurants. It looks to me like maybe food delivery simply isn't a sustainable business with 2020 technology. Or it needs a whole different business model.
- c22 6y agoSeems like it. 10-15 years ago I had a bunch of paper menus in a folder taped to my fridge that I would have to look at to order food. Perhaps I didn't have access to every restaurant in the area, but the selection was broad enough. The only extra fee I paid was whatever tip I chose to give the driver which I always assumed got added on top of a reasonable wage. That system seemed to be sustainable--at least it operated fine for many decades. It's too bad the old system was cannabilized by the apps. I'm sure some smaller operations that couldn't afford to run their own delivery before have seen an uptick in sales, but as a consumer the choice paralysis, screwed-up orders from over-worked kitchens, and insane fees/price bloat has turned getting food delivery into an unpleasant experience I now try to avoid.
- saurik 6y ago> The only extra fee I paid was whatever tip I chose to give the driver which I always assumed got added on top of a reasonable wage. I would give low odds on this assumption being true :(.
- thescriptkiddie 6y agoI think the unprofitability is purely due to inefficiency. A lot of "gig economy" companies have taken the startup model of "don't worry about profit yet, just grow as fast as possible to get investor s attention" and pushed it beyond reason. GrubHub has ~2700 employees [0], do you really need that many people to run a food delivery app that doesn't even employ delivery people? And then you get totally avoidable stupidity like pizza arbitrage [1]. There is no reason that most people on this site couldn't build an equivalent app for their city, and in fact people are doing just that [2]. [0] https://craft.co/grubhub https://craft.co/grubhub [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23216852 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23216852 [2] https://coopcycle.org/en/ https://coopcycle.org/en/
- dehrmann 6y ago> the app owners are making twice as much as the person who does all of the actual work If you look at GrubHub's financials, they're not getting rich: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/GRUB/financials?p=GRUB https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/GRUB/financials?p=GRUB 2017 was their best recent year. They had a 14% profit margin (which is OK). They lost money in 2019. CNBC says GrubHub is the only profitable delivery service: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/12/13/grubhub-uber-eats-and-doordash-drove-an-online-food-delivery-boom.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/12/13/grubhub-uber-eats-and-doorda...
- jacquesm 6y agoThey both deserve a living but the new middle man has an obligation to make their own business model work based on added value, not to cut into the - already slim - profits of their suppliers. They got in by charging very little, typically 50 cents per order or thereabouts, then changed it to a percentage of order value and then cranked up that percentage once they were in a position to strongarm their suppliers. That's unethical. If the businessmodel of a delivery service requires more margin then the company should simply pass their costs on to the buyer, not attempt to play parasite to an entire industry pretending deliver costs are next to nil (which they definitely aren't).
- mcv 6y agoI don't think it's the deliverers themselves that are the cause of the high fees, though. It's that there's an entire profit-seeking industry in between. Plenty of restaurants have their own deliverers, and they're not that expensive.