2 ms·
I love this topic of peer review. Feels like arguing about methodologies, software QA & test, learning organizations back in the 90s. Peer review and the repro
by specialist 6y ago
I love this topic of peer review. Feels like arguing about methodologies, software QA & test, learning organizations back in the 90s.
Peer review and the reproducibility crisis are the absolute bleeding edge of the human experience. Science, governance, transparency, accountability, progress, group decision making. All of it.
I encourage all the critics, thought leaders to also consider how to apply these lessons elsewhere.
Every thing said about peer review also applies to policy making, product development, news reporting, investigative journalism.
Peter Drucker, way back when, stated that management is a technology. Same applies to peer review and reproducibility.
For whatever reason, this post prompted me to think "sociology of scientific progress". I encourage critics to also factor in the collective human psychology. Covered by so many books, like the classics Structure of Scientific Revolutions and The Diffusion of Innovation. (Sorry, none of the more contemporary titles, a la Predictably Irrational, are jumping into my head at the moment.)