4 ms·
> peer review is a good first filter to reduce numbers This is only true if (a) it filters properly, and (b) scientists actually pay attention to what it filte
by pdonis 6y ago
> peer review is a good first filter to reduce numbers
This is only true if (a) it filters properly, and (b) scientists actually pay attention to what it filters.
I'm not sure either of those is actually true now (though they might have been true in the past).
> So you have cabals developing who only read each others articles and it becomes very hard for new researchers to break into
If "cabals" that are hard to break into are an issue, it's not because of lack of peer review; it's because governments are now pretty much the sole source of funding for scientific research, so there is stiff competition for grants and many people will do whatever it takes to elbow out others, including forming cabals.
The way to fix that is to not have governments be the sole (or even the primary) source of funds for scientific research.