2 ms·
> After this failure, Einstein realized there was an error in his math and redid his formula. Had the first attempt at taking photographs succeeded, we might ha
by pdonis 6y ago
> After this failure, Einstein realized there was an error in his math and redid his formula. Had the first attempt at taking photographs succeeded, we might have never heard of the man because the world might have decided he was a quack since his math didn't hold up, so, "obviously," his theory was bunk
While the failure of the first expedition might have been a factor, it was certainly not the only one. Einstein did not like a number of things about that version of his theory and probably would have revisited them anyway; his writings during this period show him going back and forth between liking the theory and thinking it's obviously wrong and needs to be patched up.
The key thing that appears to have gotten Einstein on the right path to the final 1915 version of General Relativity was a visit with David Hilbert in Gottingen in the summer of 1915. Ironically, it also got Hilbert started on a path that led to the same final field equation that Einstein found, but by a different route (a much more elegant one mathematically), and which has spawned a long-running dispute about priority [1] (though as far as I can tell, not one that either Einstein or Hilbert ever participated in--AFAIK Hilbert always credited Einstein for the main physical insights that led to General Relativity).
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativity_priority_dispute#General_relativity_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativity_priority_dispute#Ge...