2 ms·
> Einstein worked in a patent office for years, unable to get a job in academia like he wanted. Actually, while the patent office was his day job, he was worki
by pdonis 6y ago
> Einstein worked in a patent office for years, unable to get a job in academia like he wanted.
Actually, while the patent office was his day job, he was working on his Ph.D. when he published his classic 1905 papers including the one on Special Relativity. He got the Ph. D that same year, and got his first academic appointment three years later, in 1908. He didn't start working on General Relativity in earnest until about 1911 (although he had the initial ideas as early as 1907).
> There were two attempts to prove his Theory of Relativity.
More precisely, two attempts to verify one particular classic prediction of General Relativity, that of bending of light by the Sun. (The second, in 1919, btw, is now generally agreed to not have actually been a valid proof: the observations weren't actually good enough to see the effect when you take into account the appropriate error bars. But they were accepted at the time, probably in large part because of the influence of Eddington, who spearheaded the process.)
A second classic prediction, the extra precession of the perihelion of Mercury, was already known in the 19th century, but was a mystery to physicists until General Relativity explained it.
The third classic prediction of General Relativity, gravitational redshift, had to wait until the 1950s before reasonably accurate experiments were done to confirm it.
> Once there was photographic evidence supporting his theory, he became world famous overnight and then was finally able to get a job in academia, IIRC.
As noted above, he actually started working in academia well before the 1919 eclipse expeditions. But the results of those expeditions were indeed what made him world famous.
- redis_mlc 6y agoEinstein published on Brownian motion, the photoelectric effect and relativity in 1905. He was awarded the Nobel Prize for his work primarily on the photoelectic effect, not relativity. That alone would have made him famous, so I'm not sure what the thread on proving relativity is on about. https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/1921/summary/ https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/1921/summary/ (His work on relativity was probably based on his patent reviews of European train schedule calculation filings.) While I'm at it, Maxwell's equations as we know it were written by other scientists later on. Maxwell was an experimental scientist who wrote 20 formulae in longhand, and a group of scientists, including Oliver Heaviside, put them into the more compact 4 equation vector format later on. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oliver_Heaviside https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oliver_Heaviside An American physicist working as a military advisor updated one of Maxwell's equations fairly recently to correct for a minor mistake discovered during antenna research for the US government. Also, a PR pieces on extending Maxwell's equations to nanoscale: https://isn.mit.edu/cheers-maxwell%E2%80%99s-electromagnetism-extended-smaller-scales https://isn.mit.edu/cheers-maxwell%E2%80%99s-electromagnetis...
- pdonis 6y ago> He was awarded the Nobel Prize for his work primarily on the photoelectic effect, not relativity. Yes, the Nobel committee still thought relativity was too controversial to merit a prize. > That alone would have made him famous Yes, two years after he became famous because of the 1919 eclipse expedition.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pdonis 6y ago> An American physicist working as a military advisor updated one of Maxwell's equations fairly recently to correct for a minor mistake discovered during antenna research for the US government. What are you referring to? I'm not aware of any such thing.
- redis_mlc 6y agoThere was one article published on this, I'll link to it when it shows up again. Likely he's one of the few people with access to that much antenna data of various designs and powers.
- pdonis 6y ago> I'm not sure what the thread on proving relativity is on about. I don't see it as being "on about" anything. I think it's worth observing that passing peer review, in itself, does not make a scientific claim correct, and that testing scientific claims experimentally is often much more difficult, time consuming, and technologically challenging than developing them theoretically.
- adrian_b 6y agoThe larger number of the original Maxwell equations has little significance, it is due to the fact that they were equations for the components, as the vector notation was not used yet. What is important is that the original Maxwell equations were in integral form, so that they are applicable to more general cases than the differential equations of Heaviside. Even if the Heaviside equations are what is known by most people as the Maxwell equations, they are not equivalent with the original Maxwell equations. The Heaviside equations are a consequence of the original Maxwell integral equations in certain special cases (no discontinuities, no movement). Heaviside did a good job at simplifying the teaching of the Maxwell equations, but at the same time his approach resulted for many students in a superficial and incomplete understanding.
- sytelus 6y agoNo, Eienstein got his PhD in 1905 and he couldn’t find academic jobs, partly because of being Jew and partly because he had burned bridges with few professors, which is why he had to work at patent office. His special relativity paper was published after he got his PhD. At the time, there were very few journals and even fewer scientists publishing papers. You basically mail your paper and there would be one editor who would check it and if it is not very bad, it simply got published. The journal Annalen der Physik had 90-95% acceptance rate in 1905. The journals assumed role of aggregating as opposed to filtering. During those years US barely even had any PhD programs and people were expected to go to Germany to get PhD in Physics. The process only became stricter as more PhD programs started humming, more papers flowed in, more universities started popping up and journal can only have so many printed pages to be sent to its subscribers. In more recent years, number of printed pages are no longer the constraint but still available number of oral/poster slots at physical conference venues remain limited while the quantity of papers keep growing. Also, number of papers people can read are also limited which means people look for selection filters to get quality content. There are also too many people trying to publish just to have a badge as opposed to people who truly want to advance the science. This tension results in paranoia and lack of trust and hence the current review process that assumes guilty until proven sentiment from reviewers. https://theconversation.com/hate-the-peer-review-process-einstein-did-too-27405 https://theconversation.com/hate-the-peer-review-process-ein...
- pdonis 6y ago> Eienstein got his PhD in 1905 and he couldn’t find academic jobs, partly because of being Jew and partly because he had burned bridges with few professors, which is why he had to work at patent office. Einstein started working at the Swiss patent office several years before he got his Ph. D. He could not find an academic job after graduating from the Zurich Polytechnic School in 1900; that's why he ended up at the Swiss patent office. > His special relativity paper was published after he got his PhD. They were both in the same year, 1905; the actual publication date of the paper may have been after the date he was awarded his Ph. D., yes.
- sytelus 6y ago