3 ms·
> Would Einstein and Darwin have made it through peer review? I doubt it. Einstein did make it through peer review; his classic 1905 papers were published in A
by pdonis 6y ago
> Would Einstein and Darwin have made it through peer review? I doubt it.
Einstein did make it through peer review; his classic 1905 papers were published in Annalen der Physik, the most prestigious physics journal in the world at that time, after being refereed and accepted.
Darwin didn't technically go through "peer review" since he published his results in a book, not a scientific journal. But when he did so, what we now call scientific journals were extremely rare.
- BurningFrog 6y agoPeer review, in the modern sense, only became common about 40 years ago. In Einstein's time, the journal publisher decided on their own what to publish. Or so I'm told. I know that when I went through a pretty serious physics education in the early 80s, I never heard about peer review.
- btrettel 6y agoFrom what I've read the vast majority of Einstein's work was not peer reviewed. http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/three-myths-about-scientific-peer-review/ http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/three-myths-about-scientific-... > How many of Einstein’s 300 plus papers were peer reviewed? According to the physicist and historian of science Daniel Kennefick, it may well be that only a single paper of Einstein’s was ever subject to peer review.
- barry-cotter 6y agoEinstein was never published in a peer reviewed journal. Annalen der Physik had editorial review. The only time one of his articles was sent out for peer review he withdrew it from the journal in question. > For instance, the Annalen der Physik, in which Einstein published his four famous papers in 1905, did not subject those papers to the same review process. The journal had a remarkably high acceptance rate (of about 90-95%). The identifiable editors were making the final decisions about what to publish. It is the storied editor Max Planck who described his editorial philosophy as: > To shun much more the reproach of having suppressed strange opinions than that of having been too gentle in evaluating them. ... > We (Mr. Rosen and I) had sent you our manuscript for publication and had not authorised you to show it to specialists before it is printed. I see no reason to address the – in any case erroneous – comments of your anonymous expert. On the basis of this incident I prefer to publish the paper elsewhere. —- Einstein https://theconversation.com/hate-the-peer-review-process-einstein-did-too-27405 https://theconversation.com/hate-the-peer-review-process-ein...
- glofish 6y agoin Einstein's time there was very little peer review, there is a famous anecdote there, the first time that his paper was actually peer-reviewed (perhaps in the 50s) and sent back to him with instructions on what to change he wrote back something along the following lines: "there must be a mistake there, I sent in this paper for publication, not to get an opinion on how to improve it"
- scottlocklin 6y agoEditorial review is not peer review; and it's arguably the system we should be moving towards. Preprint servers mean you could appoint yourself as an editor and more or less DiY. The problem is, the way the journal system is set up; nobody wants to pay for this, and it would be career suicide to do it for free.