4 ms·
Science did well before radical ideas could be voted down by peer review. Would Einstein and Darwin have made it through peer review? I doubt it. What current
by BurningFrog 6y ago
Science did well before radical ideas could be voted down by peer review.
Would Einstein and Darwin have made it through peer review? I doubt it.
What current day people like that are held up by their "peers"? I fear we'll never know.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoWould Einstein and Darwin have made it through peer review? I doubt it. Einstein worked in a patent office for years, unable to get a job in academia like he wanted. There were two attempts to prove his Theory of Relativity. They occurred years apart because it involved photographing a total eclipse of the sun and while eclipses typically happen every six months in pairs (one solar and one lunar, though sometimes there are three in a row), most of them are partial eclipses, not total eclipses. It had to be a total eclipse to prove his theory. The first attempt to make the photograph failed. There were only two teams and it was during World War I. One was stopped or arrested or something because they were assumed to be spies. The other failed due to rain. After this failure, Einstein realized there was an error in his math and redid his formula. Had the first attempt at taking photographs succeeded, we might have never heard of the man because the world might have decided he was a quack since his math didn't hold up, so, "obviously," his theory was bunk. He probably had one and only one shot at this unusual peer review process. By the time they made the second attempt, it was something like six or eight teams of photographers trying to get a photograph of the total eclipse of the sun. Only one succeeded. I think the rest were again rained out. Nicely, it was a team that had also tried several years earlier that actually succeeded. Once there was photographic evidence supporting his theory, he became world famous overnight and then was finally able to get a job in academia, IIRC. What current day people like that are held up by their "peers"? I fear we'll never know. Me. But just saying that is likely to get me mocked. No one is trying to prove I know anything. No one wants to peer review (or otherwise check) my ideas. People mostly just want me to shut up and go away.
- pdonis 6y ago> Einstein worked in a patent office for years, unable to get a job in academia like he wanted. Actually, while the patent office was his day job, he was working on his Ph.D. when he published his classic 1905 papers including the one on Special Relativity. He got the Ph. D that same year, and got his first academic appointment three years later, in 1908. He didn't start working on General Relativity in earnest until about 1911 (although he had the initial ideas as early as 1907). > There were two attempts to prove his Theory of Relativity. More precisely, two attempts to verify one particular classic prediction of General Relativity, that of bending of light by the Sun. (The second, in 1919, btw, is now generally agreed to not have actually been a valid proof: the observations weren't actually good enough to see the effect when you take into account the appropriate error bars. But they were accepted at the time, probably in large part because of the influence of Eddington, who spearheaded the process.) A second classic prediction, the extra precession of the perihelion of Mercury, was already known in the 19th century, but was a mystery to physicists until General Relativity explained it. The third classic prediction of General Relativity, gravitational redshift, had to wait until the 1950s before reasonably accurate experiments were done to confirm it. > Once there was photographic evidence supporting his theory, he became world famous overnight and then was finally able to get a job in academia, IIRC. As noted above, he actually started working in academia well before the 1919 eclipse expeditions. But the results of those expeditions were indeed what made him world famous.
- redis_mlc 6y agoEinstein published on Brownian motion, the photoelectric effect and relativity in 1905. He was awarded the Nobel Prize for his work primarily on the photoelectic effect, not relativity. That alone would have made him famous, so I'm not sure what the thread on proving relativity is on about. https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/1921/summary/ https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/1921/summary/ (His work on relativity was probably based on his patent reviews of European train schedule calculation filings.) While I'm at it, Maxwell's equations as we know it were written by other scientists later on. Maxwell was an experimental scientist who wrote 20 formulae in longhand, and a group of scientists, including Oliver Heaviside, put them into the more compact 4 equation vector format later on. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oliver_Heaviside https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oliver_Heaviside An American physicist working as a military advisor updated one of Maxwell's equations fairly recently to correct for a minor mistake discovered during antenna research for the US government. Also, a PR pieces on extending Maxwell's equations to nanoscale: https://isn.mit.edu/cheers-maxwell%E2%80%99s-electromagnetism-extended-smaller-scales https://isn.mit.edu/cheers-maxwell%E2%80%99s-electromagnetis...
- pdonis 6y ago> After this failure, Einstein realized there was an error in his math and redid his formula. Had the first attempt at taking photographs succeeded, we might have never heard of the man because the world might have decided he was a quack since his math didn't hold up, so, "obviously," his theory was bunk While the failure of the first expedition might have been a factor, it was certainly not the only one. Einstein did not like a number of things about that version of his theory and probably would have revisited them anyway; his writings during this period show him going back and forth between liking the theory and thinking it's obviously wrong and needs to be patched up. The key thing that appears to have gotten Einstein on the right path to the final 1915 version of General Relativity was a visit with David Hilbert in Gottingen in the summer of 1915. Ironically, it also got Hilbert started on a path that led to the same final field equation that Einstein found, but by a different route (a much more elegant one mathematically), and which has spawned a long-running dispute about priority [1] (though as far as I can tell, not one that either Einstein or Hilbert ever participated in--AFAIK Hilbert always credited Einstein for the main physical insights that led to General Relativity). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativity_priority_dispute#General_relativity_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativity_priority_dispute#Ge...
- pdonis 6y ago> Would Einstein and Darwin have made it through peer review? I doubt it. Einstein did make it through peer review; his classic 1905 papers were published in Annalen der Physik, the most prestigious physics journal in the world at that time, after being refereed and accepted. Darwin didn't technically go through "peer review" since he published his results in a book, not a scientific journal. But when he did so, what we now call scientific journals were extremely rare.
- BurningFrog 6y agoPeer review, in the modern sense, only became common about 40 years ago. In Einstein's time, the journal publisher decided on their own what to publish. Or so I'm told. I know that when I went through a pretty serious physics education in the early 80s, I never heard about peer review.
- btrettel 6y agoFrom what I've read the vast majority of Einstein's work was not peer reviewed. http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/three-myths-about-scientific-peer-review/ http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/three-myths-about-scientific-... > How many of Einstein’s 300 plus papers were peer reviewed? According to the physicist and historian of science Daniel Kennefick, it may well be that only a single paper of Einstein’s was ever subject to peer review.
- barry-cotter 6y agoEinstein was never published in a peer reviewed journal. Annalen der Physik had editorial review. The only time one of his articles was sent out for peer review he withdrew it from the journal in question. > For instance, the Annalen der Physik, in which Einstein published his four famous papers in 1905, did not subject those papers to the same review process. The journal had a remarkably high acceptance rate (of about 90-95%). The identifiable editors were making the final decisions about what to publish. It is the storied editor Max Planck who described his editorial philosophy as: > To shun much more the reproach of having suppressed strange opinions than that of having been too gentle in evaluating them. ... > We (Mr. Rosen and I) had sent you our manuscript for publication and had not authorised you to show it to specialists before it is printed. I see no reason to address the – in any case erroneous – comments of your anonymous expert. On the basis of this incident I prefer to publish the paper elsewhere. —- Einstein https://theconversation.com/hate-the-peer-review-process-einstein-did-too-27405 https://theconversation.com/hate-the-peer-review-process-ein...
- cambalache 6y ago> Would Einstein and Darwin have made it through peer review? I doubt it. What are you talking about? Einstein first outstanding contributions (in his 1905 Wunderjahr) were all published in Annalen der Physik , a peer-reviewed journal. Even years after becoming a worldwide-known name, he received rejections (which he was not too much fond of). Einstein was always part of the conventional publication system of physics, Darwin , and Wallace original papers were read before the Linnean society in London and were published in its Zoology journal. You can read it here: http://darwin-online.org.uk/content/frameset?itemID=F350&viewtype=text&pageseq=1 http://darwin-online.org.uk/content/frameset?itemID=F350&vie... In the history of modern science , let's say from mid 19th century on almost the entirety of solid scientific contributions have been published via the regular channels.
- BurningFrog 6y agoNo journal had anything like the modern peer review system in 1905. That system is maybe 40 years old. You can think of it as a response to the vastly bigger volume and specialization of papers. Back then, if the editor thought the paper was decent, it got published. Perhaps the biggest problem with peer review is that your peers are often also your competitors/rivals. Imagine if each Apple product had to be approved by Google, and vice versa.
- rrss 6y agoEinstein sent his papers to Planck, and Planck, as an editor of Annalen der Physik, decided to publish them in the journal. Here's what Einstein had to say about the modern peer-review process in which a draft is reviewed by anonymous referees: > We (Mr. Rosen and I) had sent you our manuscript for publication and had not authorized you to show it to specialists before it is printed. I see no reason to address the—in any case erroneous—comments of your anonymous expert. On the basis of this incident I prefer to publish the paper elsewhere. https://physicstoday.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/1.2117822 https://physicstoday.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/1.2117822 On the other hand, Einstein was really into what we might today call post-publication peer review. A significant chunk of Einstein's publications were reviews of other scientists' publications.
- gwern 6y agoDarwin sorta did go through peer review, in one instance, giving us the immortal peer reviewer revise-and-resubmit suggestion that Darwin rewrite On The Origin of Species to focus on pigeon fancying, because "Every body is interested in pigeons." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whitwell_Elwin#Works https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whitwell_Elwin#Works