2 ms·
"judge jury and executioner"? I can't help but read that as rhetorical hyperbole. I mean, there's countless stores which post signs like "We reserve the right
by eesmith 6y ago
"judge jury and executioner"? I can't help but read that as rhetorical hyperbole.
I mean, there's countless stores which post signs like "We reserve the right to refuse service to anyone" (their power is limited, of course, to legally valid reasons). If Facebook is "judge jury and executioner" then so are countless of other organizations, to the point that your guideline is nearly ineffectual.
Facebook has already decided what it acceptable speech for their platform. Quoting the article "Facebook’s Community Standards prohibit hate speech based on race, ethnicity, and other factors because it “creates an environment of intimidation and exclusion and in some cases may promote real-world violence.” The company also bans hate organizations."
Surely they have that right, yes?
This is something which most organizations do. It is part of the right of free association. You play in someone else's court, you play by their rules.
It is entirely reasonable to have a platform which does not have those restrictions. Facebook has decided to not take that approach.
Moreover, I believe Facebook defends themselves (eg, in front of Congressional investigations) by pointing to their community standards. Their defense is reasonable only to the extent that they actually follow their own standards.
You write "If people would just say "yeah they are idiots" and ignore them"
The article comments that "Facebook’s algorithms can create an echo chamber of white supremacism through its “Related Pages” feature, which suggests similar Pages to keep users engaged on a certain topic."
That feedback mechanism won't disappear by ignoring people.
Similarly, "The remaining 64% of the white supremacy content identified by TTP involved Pages that had been auto-generated by Facebook. These Pages are automatically created by Facebook when a user lists a job in their profile that does not have an existing Page." After their report was published, 49 of the groups which were auto-generated by Facebook were removed.
That's neither suppressing acceptable speech, nor something which likely would have happened so early just by ignoring the issue.
- anm89 6y agoWhy is it hyperbole? There is zero due process, they don't have to justify their decisions, they don't have to justify the consequences of their decisions, and there is no appeals process. They are the judge, there is no jury, and they are the executioner(the one who implements the punishment). Facebook does have a right to police speech on their site. I'm not arguing whether they have that right or not. I'm saying that we shouldn't view it as desirable to want them to.