6 ms·
> There are obvious security reasons for apps like banking apps to do this This is obviously wrong. It's possible to do the same banking things using the bank'
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> There are obvious security reasons for apps like banking apps to do this
This is obviously wrong. It's possible to do the same banking things using the bank's website both from general purpose PCs and browsers on phones for which jailbreak detection is not possible in the browser.
Jailbreak detection is done by testing for the presence of common things that allow the device owner to control the device. The device owner controlling the device is not a problem for banking. Meanwhile a malicious third party wouldn't inherently need to make use of any of those and would have strong incentives to avoid using any that trigger jailbreak detection, so it's no help there either.
And for the same reason it's basically useless for detecting cheating. Because if you jailbreak your phone so you can install some apps from outside the store and then it breaks your games, you might grumble and decide you want to play the game more. But if you jailbreak your phone because you want to cheat at games, your next step is to thwart the jailbreak detection, which is not that hard when you have the game software to inspect to see how it's doing jailbreak detection. And you can also tell when the app is updated and then run the new version on a test machine to see how the new version is doing jailbreak detection.
It's hostile and a waste of time to do this when you're going to lose anyway. You only inconvenience the people who jailbreak their phones for completely unrelated reasons.
- spideymans 6y agoIf banks could secure their web portals to the same degree as their mobile apps, they absolutely would. “Portal A (web) cant be as secure as Portal B (mobile), so don’t bother securing Portal B” isn’t an acceptable security model. The banks are naturally going to reduce their vectors of attack to the greatest degree possible, and that naturally means that some access points will be more secure than others.
- cookiengineer 6y agoI am not sure where you come from, but around Europe banks are the worst when it comes to security audits, and they don’t give a damn about it. From trying to roll their own crypto, to still using legacy ssl to support ie6...everything is shitty. Even when they are forced by law [1] to integrate modern 2FA, they find ways to implement it in a shitty, proprietary way. PSD2 is required since September 2019 and every single bank rolled it out in August and waited until the very last moment. I mean, a photoTAN device with a 120x120 camera resolution? Seriously, what is this? 1999? Why not use RFC 4226 or RFC 6238 [2] [3]? [1] https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/payment-services-psd-2-directive-eu-2015-2366_en https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/payment-services-psd-2-directi... [2] https://tools.ietf.org/html/ https://tools.ietf.org/html/ [3] https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6238 https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6238
- iknowstuff 6y agoEurope's banking is pretty diverse. Some countries have very competitive, modern and innovative banking markets.
- est31 6y ago> I mean, a photoTAN device with a 120x120 camera resolution? Seriously, what is this? 1999? Why not use RFC 4226 or RFC 6238 [2] [3]? TOTP (RFC 6238) or HOTP (RFC 4226) are less secure than photoTAN/chipTAN because they are phishable, as in you can think you authorize a 30€ transfer for an internet purchase while in reality it's a 30000€ transfer to some bad people. photoTAN/chipTAN on the other hand are challenge-response based and send data about the transaction to the second factor device so that you can verify it before confirming.
- cookiengineer 6y ago> photoTAN/chipTAN on the other hand are challenge-response based and send data about the transaction to the second factor device so that you can verify it before confirming. Actually, this statement is not true, as those transactions and their payloads are not cryptographically signed and neither are they verified anyhow [1] [2]. Attackers or malicious activities on Android can easily modify the payload and still have a valid transaction for the end-user; showing up the wrong IBAN, wrong amount and wrong recipient. This applies to both the official banking apps and the photoTAN generator devices that Cronto is (re-)selling. Note that the research was made public and reposted/printed in a _lot_ of newspapers in 2016. And of course, nothing got improved. If you search the web for Uni Erlangen (FAU) and the "crypto" analysis, you'll find out that Cronto / CrontoSign is the software supplier for pretty much every major bank. And yes, it's patented, and yes, other frameworks got taken down on GitHub for copyright infringements when they tried to reverse engineer it. The only open implementation of the HBCI 2.2 / FinTS 3 [3] standard that I personally know of that hasn't been taken down already is libfintx [4]. [1] (German) https://www.fau.de/2016/10/header/phototan-banking-nicht-sicher/ https://www.fau.de/2016/10/header/phototan-banking-nicht-sic... [2] https://faui1-files.cs.fau.de/filepool/projects/matrix-code/appauth.pdf https://faui1-files.cs.fau.de/filepool/projects/matrix-code/... [3] https://www.hbci-zka.de/ https://www.hbci-zka.de/ [4] https://github.com/mrklintscher/libfintx https://github.com/mrklintscher/libfintx
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> “Portal A (web) cant be as secure as Portal B (mobile), so don’t bother securing Portal B” isn’t an acceptable security model. Which isn't the case here. A device controlled by the owner isn't less secure than one that isn't. It's only a device controlled by an attacker that is. But "jailbreak detection" only detects the former (when it even detects that) and not the latter. The fact that you can do banking on the web only proves that banks admit that you don't need a device the owner doesn't control in order to do banking.
- untog 6y ago“A device controlled by the owner” is one way of putting it. “A device capable of installing unverified software with an increased potential to introduce security vulnerabilities into the OS” is another.
- ValentineC 6y ago> “A device capable of installing unverified software with an increased potential to introduce security vulnerabilities into the OS” is another. The jailbreak community is usually quick in introducing patches for security vulnerabilities. The most recent Mail bug [1] had a patch released 29 days ago [2]. Apple only introduced a fix in a 13.4.5 beta, and it's unsure if the same fix was put into 13.5 [3]. Admittedly, it'll be even better if the community strongly encouraged the installation of such tweaks in Cydia et al. [1] https://blog.zecops.com/vulnerabilities/youve-got-0-click-mail/ https://blog.zecops.com/vulnerabilities/youve-got-0-click-ma... [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/jailbreak/comments/g7eujh/release_mailpatch_patch_the_vulnerabilities_found/ https://www.reddit.com/r/jailbreak/comments/g7eujh/release_m... [3] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT210393#135 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT210393#135
- saagarjha 6y agoClearly the fact that you can jailbreak a device really means that the non-jailbroken one wasn’t really preventing the installation of software that abuses vulnerabilities in the OS…
- lgats 6y agorelated: bank fraud detection might be port-scanning your local network. https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/08/07/halifax_bank_ports_scans/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/08/07/halifax_bank_ports_...
- smnrchrds 6y ago> It's possible to do the same banking things using the bank's website both from general purpose PCs and browsers... In my experience, this is not always the case. Some banks treat their mobile devices as more secure than website. For example, some actions would prompt an SMS MFA (I know, I know) if initiated from the website, but go right through if initiated from the app. It makes some sense, as on the app, they have access to things like location which they can use to make a better assessment on whether a request is fraudulent.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThat's not actually letting you do something different. You can still do the thing on the website, it just requires SMS. It implies they should at most only require SMS to use the app on a jailbroken phone. Or, you know, stop doing that entirely, since SMS-based authentication is horrifyingly insecure. It's literally less secure than email, and that's a pretty low bar. People should really stop using it. Also, phones have no real way of authenticating their current location, so assuming that what the phone tells you is secure against intentional fraud is a pretty bad idea to begin with.
- gengkev 6y agoOn a related note, the finance-related apps on my phone all offer me the option to sign in with a fingerprint sensor. Arguably you have two forms of authentication there: the presence of the physical device itself (using the secure element or whatever it is), as well as the biometric identifier (fingerprint scanner). Neither of those are present when logging into your bank from its website, and I would also suspect that jailbreaking a phone significantly reduces the trust you can have in either. Also, from a bank's perspective, all they care about is reducing their liability, without inconveniencing too many customers. In that context, it makes a lot of sense for banks to disallow their products from being used on jailbroken phones.
- an_opabinia 6y ago> It's hostile and a waste of time to do this when you're going to lose anyway. You only inconvenience the people who jailbreak their phones for completely unrelated reasons. I'm pretty sure jailbreaking is bad for developers who want to sell nice, simple, pay up front no surveillance software, because that is primarily threatened by the very piracy jailbreaking enables. You might imagine jailbreaking is all about giving people control or whatever. Ultimately it just means, due to piracy, that the only people that are allowed to make money off software is Google and Facebook, through ads, or other companies, which just routinely abuse the spirit of open source to monetize other people's work. Unless you're of the frankly radical opinion that anything that costs money is bad, and everything that is free is automatically better, and that the whole app ecosystem, that pays out like billions a year to actual, bonafide human beings writing software, could be instead totally supplanted by free websites. Then of course what I'm saying makes no sense.
- saagarjha 6y agoGame piracy requires exactly one jailbroken device, and that’s just because nobody has publicly cracked FairPlay yet so the easiest way to pirate a game is to just dump it from RAM once it’s been loaded and is available completely decrypted (thus necessitating the jailbreak). After that point, anyone can pirate that app, jailbroken or not.
- lucb1e 6y ago> all about giving people control or whatever Yeah, whatever. Who wants to have control over their device anyway? Much better if Apple gets to decide what I do with my iDevice. Not sure why Microsoft hasn't started the same approach, at least Linux distributions discourage people from installing software outside of the repositories, but there is much work left to be done in actually making that impossible. At least the latest innovations in home computing, smart speakers, don't allow you to run anything at all other than what the makers intended. It's great for privacy if you can't do insecure things. ... Privacy and control really are much more synonymous than at odds with each other. Sure, allowing someone to shoot themselves in the foot is something you'll want to minimize happening, but if they can't shoot themselves in the foot when they really try very hard, then how much control do they have over their private life really? > jailbreaking is bad for developers who want to sell nice, simple, pay up front no surveillance software I fail to see how this is explained by the "because" that comes after it. It just makes zero sense: why would a user taking control be bad for the developers if they don't want to surveil your device anyway? They already have the money up front, as you say. Wouldn't it make more sense to expect something to be mine after I paid for it up front? > Unless you're of the frankly radical opinion that [something exaggerated to the point where it's clearly illogical]. Then of course what I'm saying makes no sense. I'm not sure what you're trying to say here. Anyone who disagrees must be of this weird opinion and there can be no other viewpoints: either you're with you or you're illogical and "radical"?
- petersellers 6y ago> This is obviously wrong. It's possible to do the same banking things using the bank's website both from general purpose PCs and browsers on phones for which jailbreak detection is not possible in the browser. That's quite a bold statement, and also not correct in my experience. Take for example NFC payments. Both Apple and Google will disable the mobile wallet if they detect that the phone has been rooted / jailbroken.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Take for example NFC payments. Both Apple and Google will disable the mobile wallet if they detect that the phone has been rooted / jailbroken. Both Apple and Google have a conflict of interest there, so that proves nothing about the security and everything about their perverse incentives. How does it even make sense? It's safe for me to use the website from a jailbroken phone to transfer thousands of dollars to the account of a foreign national but not safe to use a jailbroken phone to pay $3 for a cup of coffee in a restaurant I'm physically standing in?
- kalmi10 6y agoI remember reading that card transactions have different costs aspects for the parties involved depending on if the card is actually physically present at the time of purchase. And iirc Apple managed to convince the banking sector that Apple Pay is equivalent to chip card security, so that they get better rates. According to reddit, Apple Pay works on jailbroken devices, but still, something like this might be at play in all the other similar scenarios.
- ValentineC 6y ago> According to reddit, Apple Pay works on jailbroken devices, but still, something like this might be at play in all the other similar scenarios. I can confirm that Apple Pay works on my jailbroken devices, and as far as I can tell, no jailbreak has managed to affect the Secure Enclave.
- SXX 6y ago
- anang 6y agoGeneral purpose PCs have a security model that takes into account that the end user has root access to the machine. OSes typically have methods to detect/mitigate exploits. A jail broken/rooted device may not have the same protections since jail breaking is typically circumventing that sort of threat protection.
- dintech 6y ago> A jail broken/rooted device may not have the same protections since jail breaking is typically circumventing that sort of threat protection. If it was jail-breakable, that security was never there in the first place.
- leviathan 6y agoYou are the one who jail-breaks the phone, but now third party apps you install can have much more unprotected access and you cannot be certain what they are doing behind your back.
- anang 6y agoJail breaking is a deliberate and involved process, in some cases something that the manufacturer even allows for. It’s not really the same as a random piece of JavaScript on a webpage jail breaking your phone. I think having a rootable device doesn’t inherently mean your device is insecure.
- ValentineC 6y ago> It’s not really the same as a random piece of JavaScript on a webpage jail breaking your phone. I think having a rootable device doesn’t inherently mean your device is insecure. Heh this was actually the case for a couple of Safari-based jailbreaks, all the way up to 9.3.4: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JailbreakMe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JailbreakMe
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> A jail broken/rooted device may not have the same protections since jail breaking is typically circumventing that sort of threat protection. So your argument is that walled garden devices are less secure assuming there exist methods to convert it into a general purpose computer, which they empirically do. Shouldn't this be an argument for such devices to be less trusted? After all, you can't always tell when this has happened (so you better assume it has), whereas as you say the devices designed to be operated under that threat model would then be more secure.
- kjaftaedi 6y agoPretty much the only thing I use my banking app for is for making purchases using my phone. (something not done with a laptop) There is no spending limit. Protection is important. You're making a poor argument based on nothing more than a loose generalization.