2 ms·
> It creates criminal liability for ambiguous fair use cases. Ah, ok, I thought that's what you might be referring to. I covered that later in my post, suggest
by pdonis 6y ago
> It creates criminal liability for ambiguous fair use cases.
Ah, ok, I thought that's what you might be referring to. I covered that later in my post, suggesting the "it's not worth the trouble to me" alternative for such cases.
What the DMCA does not provide is a way for people like the person described in the article, who know they created all the content they are posting themselves, to tell Company Y (YouTube or Github or whomever) that they are confident enough in their legal ownership of the content, because they know they created it themselves, to say so under penalty of perjury, so Company Y would already have a pre-set response to any claim of infringement. See further comments below.
> Some ambiguous cases get reinstated after a counternotice is submitted. In your system, a lawsuit would need to be filed.
Not at all. In such a case, under the DMCA, the content gets reinstated because Company Y believes the counter notice to be legitimate. In my proposed scenario, the content would never be taken down in the first place, because Company Y would have the equivalent of the counter notice (the legal document from the person who posted the content) already in hand when the complaint from Company X arrived, and would simply provide a copy to Company X (Step 2 of my process).
So this content would be chilled less under my scenario, since it wouldn't be taken down at all, whereas under the DMCA it would be taken down for up to 14 days (or even longer if it took longer for the counter notice to be filed).
- ikeboy 6y agoIn an ambiguous case, the rights owner provides their "proof" to Y, which then removes the content because they don't want to take the legal risk. Hence, content is chilled that isn't chilled under DMCA. I'm not responding to the first part of your comment, there's too many moving parts in your proposal spread across too many different comments for me to be able to figure out what you mean here. I think this conversation has gone on long enough.