4 ms·
> I have no innate right to use government roads. Yes, you do, if you're a member of the public and a taxpayer.
by pdonis 6y ago
> I have no innate right to use government roads.
Yes, you do, if you're a member of the public and a taxpayer.
- vorpalhex 6y agoCan you drive without a license or insurance? Can you legally walk down a highway?
- pdonis 6y ago> Can you drive without a license or insurance? Current law does not allow you to do this, yes. But current law also allows you to be ticketed if you exceed the speed limit. So obviously not all of current law is consistent with the basic principle I have stated. The application of the basic principle I stated to these cases should be obvious. (Btw, it seems a little odd for you to be saying, on the one hand, that certain current laws are wrong--such as the 65 mph speed limit--and on the other hand to be relying on other current laws for your understanding of what "rights" you have. Surely you should apply the same principles to all of the laws?) > Can you legally walk down a highway? I actually don't know what the law is on this one. The application of the basic principle I stated to this case, as to the ones above, should be obvious.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> > Can you drive without a license or insurance? > Current law does not allow you to do this, yes. Current law in much of the US absolutely allows this, as long as you aren't on a public road or private property where the owner has opted-in to the rules generally applicable to public roads. Of course, most of the interesting trips a person might want to take by car involve traversing public roads.
- tomrod 6y agoNobody checks these conditions when I use the roads. I could be a tax avoider and my use of the roads is unimpeded. Arrest of my use of the roads is consequent to being arrested for tax noncompliance, but I am not expressly forbidden from use of the roads. Indeed, I could go live under a bridge and never pay taxes, and I would still be able to access and use roads.
- pdonis 6y ago> Nobody checks these conditions when I use the roads. Yes, but that doesn't mean they don't apply. It is simply not worth the cost to verify that you are a taxpayer before letting you use the road.
- tomrod 6y agoVisa holders, undocumented immigrants, and more can use the roads. People without jobs, teenagers, etc. can use the roads. Your point is made without evidence and without observational adherence to reality as I've experienced it. Do you have a source you can direct me to showing me the requirement that any publicly (taxpayer) funded road is only usable by taxpayers?
- pdonis 6y ago> the requirement that any publicly (taxpayer) funded road is only usable by taxpayers? I never stated any such requirement. What I did say was that taxpayers have a right to use public roads. That is not the same as saying anyone else is prohibited from using them. The latter is a matter of how we choose to make public policy. Our current public policy is that anyone is, in practice, allowed to use public roads, whether they are taxpayers or not. We could choose a different, more restrictive public policy regarding non-taxpayers, but we don't. (That is probably, as I said before, because it's not worth the cost to check everyone using public roads to see their taxpayer status.) But we cannot, at least not based on the legal principle I stated, choose a public policy that does not allow taxpayers to use public roads, since they have a right to do so.
- tomrod 6y agoSo no source on the claim that one must be a taxpayer to use (i.e. exercise the right to be on) public roads? If the right is not enumerated, then it probably isn't restricted to taxpayers. Right of mobility is a natural right.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Yes, you do, if you're a member of the public and a taxpayer. The idea that being a taxpayer gives you an innate right of use of government resources is bizarre. Being a citizen gives you an innate right of supervision, of course, but being a taxpayer doesn't add anything to that, and supervision isn't use.
- pdonis 6y ago> The idea that being a taxpayer gives you an innate right of use of government resources is bizarre. They're not "government resources", they're public resources. We all collectively own them. The government is an agent that we use to manage those resources, but it doesn't own them. The public does.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoI think the confusion stems from the fact that US citizens are used to thinking of "the government" not as their representative but as an independent agent that has its own interests that don't necessarily align with their own interests. A powerful institution that can compel them to do things they don't like. Sort of like banks. This is something that has always made me wonder. The libertarian ideal of "less government" makes more sense if one sees the government as above, an independent agent with its own interests. As a citizen of an EU nation, the way I think of it is that voters elect a government to represent them, so "less government" means "less power to voters to represent themselves". But to libertarians it means "more freedom". So when the government compels you to "shelter in place", social-distance, wear a mask and so on, it is clearly not doing that because it is trying to protect you, because government is not an agent that has your own best interests in mind, but its own. Instead, it's trying to take away your freedom, because that is what government does, it takes away your freedoms. That's my best explanation, as someone who has never lived in the US. In any case it's clear that the question of "mask or no mask" has become politicised by being caught up in this peculiar interpretation of "freedom". Which is very unfortunate because it's not a political matter, whether everyone wearing masks makes it less likely that anyone will catch the virus. It's a practical matter and what is necessary is a practical decision. But such practical decisions cannot be taken when everything has to be politicised.
- vorpalhex 6y agoAs a taxpayer you benefit from the roads as a non-driver because of interstate commerce. That you get to go on nice roadtrips is a side benefit.