3 ms·
> all the DMCA does is create a safe harbor. It doesn't require the site to take down the content. They're free to do their own investigation and refuse to take
by pdonis 6y ago
> all the DMCA does is create a safe harbor. It doesn't require the site to take down the content. They're free to do their own investigation and refuse to take it down, they just run the risk of being liable if they get it wrong.
And yet, even the corporations like YouTube who can most afford to do the latter--to both investigate claims on their own, and to defend their decisions in court--don't. So this alternative is meaningless in practice.
Also, you say elsewhere that YouTube is not the business of suing people frivolously (with which I agree), so a person who wants to post content might feel ok making a contract with them but not ok about being subjected to a lawsuit by some arbitrary company.
Now take this a step further: wouldn't it be nice if YouTube, a company who far more afford to do so than the average person, were to include in their contract that, if they find that an infringement claim against a user's content is invalid, they will keep the content posted and defend it, if necessary, in court, and not require the user to do so? Or, better yet, they could give the user the option: either the user signs up for the "YouTube will defend my content if they believe it's legitimate" option, and provides the legal documentation supporting their legal ownership of copyright for the content they provide; or the user checks the box that says "if anyone complains that my content is infringing their copyright, just take it down and leave it at that, it's not worth the trouble to me".
That, or something like it, is what I would expect to happen in a sane legal regime, where the law did not impose a one-size-fits-all solution on everybody, but treated everyone fairly and reasonably and allowed people with different preferences to find different solutions that suited them. But the DMCA "chills" all of that by providing even large corporations like YouTube, who least need it, a "safe harbor" that absolves them from having to do any work at all on actually figuring out how to meet the different needs of different users.
- ikeboy 6y agoYouTube does, in fact, have a program to defend fair use, and they reject DMCA notices in those cases. But it's expensive and they can't do it in every case. Lawyers are expensive. YouTube gets sued enough by idiots who think the DMCA safe harbor doesn't apply for whatever reason. Anyway, I disagree that YouTube doesn't need the safe harbor. If they had to pay a lawyer for a minute of time for every DMCA request received, they'd lose money. YouTube did innovate. They created a system for the largest content creators which automated complaints and created a special appeals process, which discourages DMCA complaints. They also placed protections on this program and ban people from it that submit too many false complaints.