3 ms·
That article makes a good argument for immunity passports. - People don't seem to be getting this disease twice in three months, even if exposed again. So ther
by Animats 7y ago
That article makes a good argument for immunity passports.
- People don't seem to be getting this disease twice in three months, even if exposed again. So there's clearly some level of immunity. In a month, we'll know if it's good for four months. It doesn't have to be lifetime. A year or two would be enough. By then there will be either a vaccine or herd immunity.
- The first batch of rushed antibody tests were not very good, but there are reliable antibody tests now. Above 99%, anyway. That's good enough.
- If huge numbers of tests will fix the problem, that just takes money. Far cheaper than a 3 trillion dollar "stimulus". Cost goes down with volume, too.
- Too few survivors - right now, yes; over time, no. New York City is somewhere in the 15% - 20% range now. By the time the plan is in place, there will be more.
- As for "marginalized groups", this seems to hit Asians and blacks worse. So those groups will have more survivors, more immunity passports, and better access to jobs.
- buboard 7y ago> right now, yes; over time, no. the rate of infection (and immunity development) is going down everywhere. it seems high immunity level will take too many months to arrive even in the most affected cities. By that time the virus will have mutated, like other coronaviruses
- Animats 7y agothe rate of infection (and immunity development) is going down everywhere. No, it's not.[1] Some places it's up, some places it's down. The US as a whole is flat right now. [1] https://ig.ft.com/coronavirus-chart/?areas=usa&areas=gbr&areasRegional=usny&areasRegional=usnj&cumulative=0&logScale=0&perMillion=1&values=cases https://ig.ft.com/coronavirus-chart/?areas=usa&areas=gbr&are...
- buboard 7y agothe graph shows new cases are down from the peak and decreasing. this means immunity development is going to be a lot slower than it has been until now
- aeturnum 7y ago> - As for "marginalized groups", this seems to hit Asians and blacks worse. So those groups will have more survivors, more immunity passports, and better access to jobs. What you're describing is a perfectly fair system, but that is not how marginalization works in practice. I can't see the future, but I imagine that groups who strongly associated with corona virus would face much greater scrutiny when obtaining documentation. Historical examples of this kind of effect can be seen in civil war pension discrimination[0] and in the general belief in racial stereotypes[1]. There's every reason to believe that the factors that make a group vulnerable would be redoubled in through a certification process. [0] https://news.byu.edu/news/racial-discrimination-union-army-pensions-detailed-new-study https://news.byu.edu/news/racial-discrimination-union-army-p... [1] https://www.aamc.org/news-insights/how-we-fail-black-patients-pain https://www.aamc.org/news-insights/how-we-fail-black-patient...
- FabHK 7y ago> Above 99%, anyway. That's good enough. You know that if you have a 3% prevalence of the virus in the population, and test 100 people with a test that has 99% specificity and sensitivity, then 3 will be positive, and most likely test positive, but 1 will test positive despite being negative. Thus, of the 4 people testing positive, only 3 will have antibodies and immunity. Not sure that's good enough. (Note that this problem diminishes not only as the tests get better, but as the virus spreads more.)