3 ms·
From my understanding, it should be the other way around that's proved. Because that's kinda how the immunity system works. AFAIK the viruses that you don't get
by godelski 6y ago
From my understanding, it should be the other way around that's proved. Because that's kinda how the immunity system works. AFAIK the viruses that you don't get immunity from (assuming you get it and recover) are the odd ones. Like HIV, and from what I know there can be hundreds or thousands of variations of the virus inside a single person.
- jniedrauer 6y agoThere are viruses where immunity to one strain makes subsequent infections with other strains much worse[0]. So far there only seems to be one strain of SARS-CoV-2, but it's definitely a risk worth considering. [0]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4333201/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4333201/
- jpollock 6y agoChickenpox is another one, it can re-erupt as shingles when older. My googling also turns up herpes, Epstein-Barr, measles(!), HPV, Hep-B [1]... It looks like there are many diseases which can find a host reservoir in our body to hide out for a while. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK8538/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK8538/
- mc32 6y agoEbola too, i think would hide in peoples’s eyes and come back in some cases, if I recall correctly.
- godelski 6y agoSo there's nuance to this that's important. Let's look at measles[0] because we get vaccinated for it (which shows that we can get immunity) but the report says that 9% of cases were people who had been vaccinated. The crux of this is that immunity doesn't last forever but does last for awhile. In measles it looks like 15 years after your two standard MMR vaccines you get from a kid. We have to recognize too that vaccines aren't perfect. Your immune system might not make as strong of an antibody response as another person. You may lose immunity sooner than others. Etc. But the whole premise of the vaccine is that you can get immunity. And if we look at this study, this worked out for most people. Not many people got measles, and of those that did only 9% were vaccinated, which shows that there is a substantial bias for those that weren't vaccinated. So when I'm saying that people get get immunity I don't mean forever and to every strain, but that they generally get some protection. In fact, this is an essential component to vaccine theory. If you gain __NO__ immunity (for any period of time) from covid, then a vaccine isn't going to do anything because you can't build an immunity. If you get immunity for a year (like with the flu), I think that's a pretty acceptable risk for many and shows that we could build substantial herd immunity just with the younger populations (like with the flu, which the vaccine there isn't even that great, but better than nothing). And as another note on Shingles, I don't know about you, but chickenpox parties (because it is A LOT worse when you're older) were a thing when I was a kid (I'm not even 30!) and less than 1% of people get shingles. The main factors are being old, immunocompromised, and getting chickenpox before you're 18 months old. Saying you can get reinfected and will get reinfected are different statements with different risk values. [0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4979181/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4979181/
- mrob 6y ago"Evidence" in this context is medical jargon, not the common meaning of the word. It means "results from randomized controlled trials". There is also "weak evidence" (results from non-randomized trials). I wish they'd make the distinction clear, because if people assume it's the same word they end up thinking the medical professionals are liars or idiots. It's true that all those other viruses are "evidence" in the normal sense, but that's not what they mean.
- godelski 6y agoImmunity in this context doesn't mean immunity forever or 100%. Vaccines provide "immunity" but they don't last forever and don't work perfectly on everyone.
- robbrown451 6y agoYes and with HIV, people don't tend to get well on their own. Once you show symptoms, you can't just wait for your immune system to kick in. With COVID-19, clearly people get well. This isn't to say it will protect you forever, and isn't to say there can't be variants that can infect you. But still...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]