4 ms·
> In other words, YouTube wouldn't exist, because it's impractical for YouTube to verify every single video I never said they had to "verify every single video
by pdonis 6y ago
> In other words, YouTube wouldn't exist, because it's impractical for YouTube to verify every single video
I never said they had to "verify every single video". They just need the legal document I describe. The whole point of having the document is that that is the "verification"; they don't have to try to independently scrutinize everything. They are putting the legal burden on the person posting the content, which is where it belongs.
The "obvious next question" I gave was for websites that don't have the legal document I describe. Whicn some random person trying to let other random people post infringing content would not have. But YouTube certainly could have it. The only reason it doesn't now is that we live in an insane legal regime that thinks the DMCA is just fine, instead of being the draconian mess that it is.
> No other website powered by user generated content would exist.
Websites powered by user generated content have an obvious way to exist under a sane legal regime: if there is a cost involved in obtaining the appropriate legal affirmation from users who post content, then charge those users for the services being provided, and include in those charges the costs of dealing with the legal requirements.
But again, we live in an insane world where it's thought to be better to prop up the ad-supported business model, with all of its many serious flaws, than to have the law actually be reasonable and force large corporations to figure out business models that actually serve their users instead of selling their data.
- ikeboy 6y agoSo you would effectively destroy all free user generated content sites, and a good portion of the cheap ones as well. Just good to make that clear upfront when evaluating your proposal, so people could decide if this is really less draconian than the current system.
- pdonis 6y ago> So you would effectively destroy all free user generated content sites If it's impossible to do reasonable due diligence without charging users, yes. Posting content has a cost; it is entirely reasonable for users who want to post the content to bear at least a portion of that cost. > a good portion of the cheap ones as well Depends on what you mean by "cheap" and how much it would cost to actually do reasonable due diligence in a sane legal regime. I don't think it would cost much at all per user, particularly for a site like YouTube which has so many users. Which brings up another point: a large corporation like Google, owning a site like YouTube, is precisely the kind of corporation that ought to figure out a cheap way to do reasonable due diligence and handle things like having people provide a legal document before they upload content, and work with the legal system to develop a way of dealing with this that is fair and reasonable to all parties. And yet they are too lazy to do that, and depend on draconian laws instead to give them a supposed "safe harbor" against claims that, in a sane world, they would be able to refute and dismiss with minimal effort. And, further, the government is precisely the entity that, when large corporations fail to do what they ought to do, is supposed to make them do it, as the representative of the interests of the people. What our government did, instead, was to simply capitulate to the demands of the large corporations, and to fail to require them to do any due diligence at all, instead putting all the burden on the individuals who are posting legitimate content they created that gets mistaken by some corporation for copyrighted content--or the corporation simply decides not to care whether the content is infringing or not, because they see value in showing everyone else that they can bully whomever they want and not get stopped. And you are arguing that all this is perfectly fine and proper. Just to make that clear upfront so people know what you are really saying.
- ikeboy 6y agoYouTube did come up with a solution to one of the issues with DMCA - that it requires a manual report. They allowed sophisticated rights owners to upload content and then automatically flag any uploads that match. This is done outside of the DMCA and has no negative effect on users accounts, and comes with an appeal option. This is somewhat of an improvement on the DMCA, and it's voluntary for rights owners so it doesn't violate the DMCA. It's successfully reduced the number of DMCA complaints YouTube receives. I still don't quite understand what aspect of the law you consider draconian. Is removing a video for 14 days such a terrible downside that you'd get rid of the whole framework? Or are there other parts you object to? As above, I don't believe the DMCA is perfect. So please don't accuse me of thinking it is. I think penalties for false claims should be increased, I think false claims should be strict liability and antitrust per se. But I think getting rid of the entire framework would be a mistake.
- pdonis 6y ago> I still don't quite understand what aspect of the law you consider draconian. The fact that it accepts complaints as factual and valid without evidence and without any legal due process for conflicting claims. Conflicting claims are supposed to be decided by a court, and neither party is supposed to have their claim accepted as fact and acted on until a court has decided.
- ikeboy 6y agoAccepting a DMCA complaint doesn't mean it's factual or valid. It simply means the content is removed for 14 days, if a valid counternotice is submitted and no lawsuit is filed. So to be clear - the 14 day period is what you consider draconian?
- pdonis 6y ago> Accepting a DMCA complaint doesn't mean it's factual or valid. Yes, it does, because the content gets taken down. That means treating the content as if it does infringe copyright. That means treating the claim of infringement as valid. Saying "well, we aren't accepting it as valid, but we're still taking down the content anyway" is just sophistry. Taking down the content is accepting the claim as valid, or would be in any sane legal regime. But we don't live in a sane legal regime.
- ikeboy 6y agoOne of two things must be true. Either this legal affirmation is simple enough to get that it doesn't actually reduce infringement much (and thus making infringement much more of a problem by removing any way of handling it other than lawsuits), or it's more complicated and creates a significant barrier to legitimate works being published.
- pdonis 6y ago> One of two things must be true. No, you are simply setting up a false dichotomy. You are also ignoring the fact that, in a sane legal regime, if a large number of people legitimately want to post content to some place like YouTube, and that place is charging users directly for their services, as they should, then places like that can simply ask the sane legal regime to consider ways of letting people, for example, provide a single legal affirmation when they sign up for an account that covers all content they post under that account. Then the site could just have a reminder on the "post this content" screen that basically says "remember that you gave us a legal affirmation which makes you liable for any copyright violation, so if we get a claim of copyright infringement and it turns out it's legitimate, we're coming after you". Legal systems have been dealing with reasonable issues like this since forever. A sane legal system is perfectly capable of evolving in response to new technologies, without compromising basic principles like "innocent until proven guilty", requirements to back up legal claims with evidence, handling claims through appropriate channels and not short-circuiting them, and fairness to all parties.
- ikeboy 6y agoIt's not a false dichotomy, it's an unavoidable trade-off. You haven't given enough details on your proposal for me to tell where this trade-off is made, but you can't avoid this trade-off. Now you seem to be implying this affirmation is simply a contractual indemnification, which of course YouTube already has: >To the extent permitted by applicable law, you agree to defend, indemnify and hold harmless YouTube, its Affiliates, officers, directors, employees and agents, from and against any and all claims, damages, obligations, losses, liabilities, costs or debt, and expenses (including but not limited to attorney's fees) arising from: (i) your use of and access to the Service; (ii) your violation of any term of this Agreement; (iii) your violation of any third party right, including without limitation any copyright, property, or privacy right; or (iv) any claim that your Content caused damage to a third party. This defense and indemnification obligation will survive this Agreement and your use of the Service. >For example, the Content you submit must not include third-party intellectual property (such as copyrighted material) unless you have permission from that party or are otherwise legally entitled to do so. It's not clear to me from the rest of your comments whether you believe this to be sufficient. If it is, then clearly this isn't enough to prevent infringement, and killing DMCA as an option would make it significantly more difficult to remove infringing content. Which might be what you want, I don't know. But the trade-off is real. >Legal systems have been dealing with reasonable issues like this since forever. A sane legal system is perfectly capable of evolving in response to new technologies, without compromising basic principles like "innocent until proven guilty", requirements to back up legal claims with evidence, handling claims through appropriate channels and not short-circuiting them, and fairness to all parties. Legal systems have been making a series of trade-offs for a long time. The trade-off here is that sometimes content is removed for up to 14 days and then put back. In exchange for that, there's a way for rights owners to resolve issues out of court.