4 ms·
MongoDB's big problem is that their present user base does not want the problems fixed, particularly at default settings, because it would mean going slower. Th
by ncmncm 6y ago
MongoDB's big problem is that their present user base does not want the problems fixed, particularly at default settings, because it would mean going slower. Their users are self-selected as not caring much about integrity and durability. There are lots of applications where those qualities are just not very important, but speed is. People with such applications do need help with data management, and have money to spend on it.
The stock market wants to see the product as a competitor with Oracle, so demands all the certifications that say so. MongoDB marketing wants to be able to collect money as if the product were competitive. Many of the customers have management that would be embarrassed to spend that kind of money on a database that is not. And, ultimately, many of the applications do have durability requirements for some of the data.
So, MongoDB's engineers are pulled in one direction by actual (paying) users, and the opposite direction by the money people. It's not a good place to be. They have very competent engineers, but they have set themselves a problem that might not be solvable under their constraints, and that they might not be able to prove they have solved, if they did. Time spent on it does not address what most customers want to see progress on.
- threeseed 6y agoIf they only cared about performance then they would've left the write concern defaults to not acknowledge writes either locally or within a replica set. Or just read from the nearest replica and don't worry about potential consistency issues. Also this isn't 2011. MongoDB is not a competitor to Oracle and never really has been by people that knew that a DocumentDB was not usable as a SQL one. It's other SQL databases that are the real competitors e.g. Snowflake, Redshift are.
- ncmncm 6y agoYou know it, I know it, MDB knows it, and most of their customers know it, but that doesn't matter: the stock market doesn't. MDB wants to be valued like a durable-database company, and to be able to charge durable-database prices. They need a plausible durable-database story to get those, regardless of what actual current users want. It is possible there are still potential users not buying until they get that story. MDB wants those users.
- gwbas1c 6y agoTranslation: They were trying to be everything for everybody. The syntax is very nice, I honestly think a lot of it's early success came from ease of use.