5 ms·
> What do you mean by legally valid? I mean the same standard that would be used for any other statement or deposition that was presented as evidence or testim
by pdonis 6y ago
> What do you mean by legally valid?
I mean the same standard that would be used for any other statement or deposition that was presented as evidence or testimony in a court. Normally that requires a statement made upon oath or affirmation and witnessed by a notary public or an officer of the court.
> Is there a difference between the proposed "affirmation" and what a counternotice currently says?
Yes, there's the obvious difference that the affirmation has to be provided before the content is posted, instead of after a DMCA notice has already been made (and in many cases the alleged infringing content will already have been taken down, assuming guilt instead of innocence).
Under a sane legal regime, YouTube would have an affirmation, under the standards described above, before it ever allowed any content to be posted. So its first response on receiving a complaint of copyright infringement would be to provide a copy of that affirmation to whoever was making the complaint. Then whoever was making the complaint would have to provide some kind of evidence that that affirmation was fraudulent in order to get YouTube to pay attention. They wouldn't just be able to assert without any evidence that the content was infringing and have it taken down.
In practice, under a sane legal regime, the vast majority of people who might want to post infringing content would not even be willing to go to the trouble of submitting an affirmation in the first place. The people who would (aside from large corporations) would be people who genuinely are creating something they want others to see, and want it enough to be willing to go through the affirmation process.
- ikeboy 6y ago>I mean the same standard that would be used for any other statement or deposition that was presented as evidence or testimony in a court. Normally that requires a statement made upon oath or affirmation and witnessed by a notary public or an officer of the court. You don't need a notary for affidavits, just a sworn declaration. Anyway, would you require anyone who posts content to agree to US jurisdiction, as the counternotice process currently allows? And how would the penalties for copyright infringement after such an affidavit were submitted look like in your system, as compared to the penalties for copyright infringement currently, or compared to the penalties for submitting a false counternotice currently? Do you realize there would be a significant chilling effect on fair use speech under your proposal?
- pdonis 6y ago> You don't need a notary for affidavits, just a sworn declaration. I think this depends on the jurisdiction, but anyway, "sworn" still means someone like an officer of the court has to be present, and the affidavit has to show that that was the case. You can't just write "sworn" at the end of something you wrote with no one else present and call it an affidavit. > would you require anyone who posts content to agree to US jurisdiction It would be the jurisdiction that has legal power over the corporation that is hosting the content. So if that corporation is a US corporation, then yes, it would be US jurisdiction. If claims of copyright infringement are going to be allowed at all (and if they're not, this whole discussion is pointless), then they have to be made under some jurisdiction. I believe what I said above is how such claims would be handled if the DMCA did not exist. > how would the penalties for copyright infringement after such an affidavit were submitted look like in your system, as compared to the penalties for copyright infringement currently They would be the same, since copyright infringement as an offense remains the same. > compared to the penalties for submitting a false counternotice currently I don't think DMCA penalties are a useful comparison since they're not the product of a fair and reasonable legal process to begin with. > Do you realize there would be a significant chilling effect on fair use speech under your proposal? There would? How so?
- ikeboy 6y ago>You can't just write "sworn" at the end of something you wrote with no one else present and call it an affidavit. I mean, I've personally submitted a declaration to a court, and all I did was digitally sign a document and email it to my lawyer. No notary required. Re jurisdiction: the current law doesn't require anyone posting on YouTube to accept US jurisdiction to anyone who wants to sue for infringement - they only require that if someone wants to file a counternotice. I think this is good. Posting a video shouldn't open you up to jurisdiction everywhere, but insisting your content remain accessible in the US in the face of an infringement allegation should. If your proposed affidavit doesn't increase the penalties for infringement, then the only purpose is to enforce jurisdiction? Re chilling effect: it depends on how relevant this affirmation is. I still don't think I understand exactly what you mean. But if it's enough to chill some infringement, then it's going to chill some legitimate speech as well, and if it's going to significantly chill infringement then it will significantly chill legitimate speech. That's the lesson of history. Every attempt at making it easier to censor has this effect. You can't avoid this trade-off.