4 ms·
> You're just saying that the DMCA notice system should be abolished. I think the entire DMCA should be abolished. > it provides a safe harbor to YouTube Why
by pdonis 6y ago
> You're just saying that the DMCA notice system should be abolished.
I think the entire DMCA should be abolished.
> it provides a safe harbor to YouTube
Why should YouTube have a safe harbor over and above making users who post content provide an affirmation, valid in a court of law, that they are the rightful owners of the content? Any prudent provider of hosting for content to random people on the Internet would do this.
If the answer is that YouTube couldn't possibly do this for all of the millions of people who want to post content, how is that anything but YouTube's problem? Why should a draconian law be put in place simply to allow them to avoid having to do proper due diligence? Or to allow companies like Casio who want to bully people to be able to skip having to actually file a lawsuit?
> In your system, we'd have to say nobody can sue YouTube regardless unless they don't comply with a court order
No, we'd have to say that, once YouTube shows the court the legally valid affirmation it got from the user, such a suit would be dismissed. Which means, in practice, that when YouTube's lawyers sent the lawyers for whoever was complaining (Casio in this case) a copy of that legally valid affirmation, Casio's lawyers would tell Casio that they had no chance of winning a lawsuit and they should drop it. And if Casio tried to sue regardless, any reasonable judge would dismiss the suit and tell Casio to stop wasting the court's time (if the judge didn't decide to slap a fine on them for a frivolous lawsuit).
> this makes it too easy for someone to set up an infringing website and simply say that someone else uploaded all the content
Which would then bring the obvious next question: how did you confirm that the someone else was the rightful owner of all the content? And the answer "we didn't" would mean the infringing website owner would lose the lawsuit.
- ikeboy 6y agoWhat do you mean by legally valid? Is there a difference between the proposed "affirmation" and what a counternotice currently says? >Which would then bring the obvious next question: how did you confirm that the someone else was the rightful owner of all the content? And the answer "we didn't" would mean the infringing website owner would lose the lawsuit. In other words, YouTube wouldn't exist, because it's impractical for YouTube to verify every single video. No other website powered by user generated content would exist. And now you know why the DMCA is needed. Unless of course you think we could do without any website hosting third party content.
- pdonis 6y ago> What do you mean by legally valid? I mean the same standard that would be used for any other statement or deposition that was presented as evidence or testimony in a court. Normally that requires a statement made upon oath or affirmation and witnessed by a notary public or an officer of the court. > Is there a difference between the proposed "affirmation" and what a counternotice currently says? Yes, there's the obvious difference that the affirmation has to be provided before the content is posted, instead of after a DMCA notice has already been made (and in many cases the alleged infringing content will already have been taken down, assuming guilt instead of innocence). Under a sane legal regime, YouTube would have an affirmation, under the standards described above, before it ever allowed any content to be posted. So its first response on receiving a complaint of copyright infringement would be to provide a copy of that affirmation to whoever was making the complaint. Then whoever was making the complaint would have to provide some kind of evidence that that affirmation was fraudulent in order to get YouTube to pay attention. They wouldn't just be able to assert without any evidence that the content was infringing and have it taken down. In practice, under a sane legal regime, the vast majority of people who might want to post infringing content would not even be willing to go to the trouble of submitting an affirmation in the first place. The people who would (aside from large corporations) would be people who genuinely are creating something they want others to see, and want it enough to be willing to go through the affirmation process.
- ikeboy 6y ago>I mean the same standard that would be used for any other statement or deposition that was presented as evidence or testimony in a court. Normally that requires a statement made upon oath or affirmation and witnessed by a notary public or an officer of the court. You don't need a notary for affidavits, just a sworn declaration. Anyway, would you require anyone who posts content to agree to US jurisdiction, as the counternotice process currently allows? And how would the penalties for copyright infringement after such an affidavit were submitted look like in your system, as compared to the penalties for copyright infringement currently, or compared to the penalties for submitting a false counternotice currently? Do you realize there would be a significant chilling effect on fair use speech under your proposal?
- beervirus 6y agoThat affirmation would be meaningless. Without the DMCA's safe harbor, YouTube would be on the hook for copyright infringement even if the person posting the video affirmed super seriously that he owned the content.
- pdonis 6y ago> Without the DMCA's safe harbor, YouTube would be on the hook for copyright infringement even if the person posting the video affirmed super seriously that he owned the content. I have no idea where you are getting that from. If YouTube has prima facie evidence that the content is not infringing, which is what the affirmation provides, then any lawsuit against them would be dismissed unless the plaintiff could prove that the affirmation was fraudulent. And even then all YouTube would be liable for would be taking down the content by court order, unless the plaintiff could also show that YouTube knew or should have known that the affirmation was fraudulent. What the DMCA does is remove any requirement on the plaintiff to prove that content they claim infringes their copyright, actually infringes their copyright. The plaintiff can simply assert it and have that assertion taken as fact without proof. That's not "safe harbor"; that's an egregious misuse of the law.
- beervirus 6y ago> If YouTube has prima facie evidence that the content is not infringing, which is what the affirmation provides, then any lawsuit against them would be dismissed unless the plaintiff could prove that the affirmation was fraudulent. That's not how this works. If the plaintiff owns the copyrighted material, it would be trivial to show that the affirmation wasn't true. > And even then all YouTube would be liable for would be taking down the content by court order, unless the plaintiff could also show that YouTube knew or should have known that the affirmation was fraudulent. Where did that "knew or should have known" standard come from?
- pdonis 6y ago> If the plaintiff owns the copyrighted material, it would be trivial to show that the affirmation wasn't true. The question is not whether the plaintiff owns "the copyrighted material". The question is whether whatever was posted is the copyrighted material, or derived from it under circumstances that do not fall within one of the exceptions given in copyright law (such as fair use), or not. That is a question that should be decided, if it gets to that point, by a court of law. It is not a question that should be decided by the bare assertion of the plaintiff, as it was in this case under the DMCA regime. > Where did that "knew or should have known" standard come from? From the general language of civil law for assessing liability.