2 ms·
Responding only to this part: > The only disadvantage is if the rights owner is willing to file a frivolous lawsuit, and in that scenario their lawyers can get
by loeg 6y ago
Responding only to this part:
> The only disadvantage is if the rights owner is willing to file a frivolous lawsuit, and in that scenario their lawyers can get sanctioned by the court.
It's difficult in many jurisdictions for a defendant to actually get even their lawyers' fees covered by a frivolous litigant, much less sanctions for the litigant and/or their lawyers. Especially if, as the initiating party, they pick a friendly jurisdiction without anti-SLAPP laws.
- ikeboy 6y agoI'm not quite sure about that framing. Every jurisdiction reserves the right to sanction attorneys for frivolous cases. The framing I'd prefer is that there are meritless cases that don't quite rise to the level of frivolous; the legal terminology here is "a good faith extension of existing law." I think the legal system properly doesn't penalize such cases. If a case isn't sanctionable, we need to accept the consequences as a trade-off for allowing everyone access to the courts. That being said, I support stronger anti-slapp laws - and I say this as someone who's faced a meritless and possibly frivolous anti-SLAPP motion myself (discussed in other recent HN threads). Personally, the anti-slapp laws have only hurt me, and I still support their expansion.
- loeg 6y agoThey reserve the right to sanction, but it rarely happens, even for repeated infringers. And I disagree with your framing. There are plenty of truly frivolous cases brought to harass or compel poorer entities, and it mostly works (maybe less well against speech in jurisdictions with anti-SLAPP).
- ikeboy 6y agoI feel uncomfortable with an alternative world where it's significantly easier to sanction attorneys. I suspect many legitimate cases would not end up being brought, and legal costs would go up. There's a trade-off to be made.