4 ms·
Yeah there was the fraudulent fallout map. Yeah somebody who hadn't slept in a week may have misspoken and used the term "nuclear explosion" when they really me
by marshray 16y ago
Yeah there was the fraudulent fallout map. Yeah somebody who hadn't slept in a week may have misspoken and used the term "nuclear explosion" when they really meant "conventional explosion involving nuclear material".
I haven't seen a lot of overreaction. People are still in Tokyo even while detectable radiation levels rise to many times background levels.
What I have seen is a huge number of media outlets and bloggers falling over themselves to assure everyone that everyone is safe and everything is under control. And they look more and more wrong with every new explosion and every new fire at the plant.
The real heroes are the 50 plant workers who are there putting water on the melting fuel rods.
- rmc 16y agoThere has been some fear mongering in the press. E.g. The London Evening Standard: "Nuclear Fallout hits U.S. Rescurers" http://yfrog.com/h3z17vzj http://yfrog.com/h3z17vzj
- marshray 16y agoI can only see the main and sub-headlines and the picture. But I don't see anything factually incorrect about it.
- glenjamin 16y agoJust because it's factually correct doesn't mean its not scaremongering.
- marshray 16y ago...and just because it's scary doesn't mean it is. Tens of thousands of people have been evacuated in a 20 km radius and many more are sheltering indoors due to a nuclear emergency. No exaggeration is needed to say this is a scary big deal, and calling it like it is isn't "mongering".
- Alex3917 16y ago"What I have seen is a huge number of media outlets [...] falling over themselves to assure everyone that everyone is safe and everything is under control." Not surprising, considering most of those media outlets are owned or funded by the nuclear power industry. edit: http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6t515_conspiracy-theory-rock_shortfilms http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6t515_conspiracy-theory-ro...
- gammarator 16y agoThere are reports of runs on iodine on the US west coast [1], which are not based on any scientific assessment of risk. [1] http://blogs.aljazeera.net/live/asia/japans-nuclear-emergency-live-blog#update-12446 http://blogs.aljazeera.net/live/asia/japans-nuclear-emergenc...
- mseebach 16y ago> What I have seen is a huge number of media outlets and bloggers falling over themselves to assure everyone that everyone is safe and everything is under control. Perhaps in response to a huge number of media outlets and bloggers falling over themselves to link Fukushima to Chernobyl and gloating over being right that nuclear power is going to kill us all.
- VladRussian 16y agomy previous 2c : http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2324723 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2324723 Read more about Chernobyl and nuclear technology and you'd be able to see yourself where similarity is and where isn't.
- mseebach 16y agoAt Fukushima, the core reaction is shut down, all activity since seconds after the quake are secondary. This is bad enough, but it's fundamentally different from Chernobyl, where the core melted down with the control rods only 1/3 inserted.
- marshray 16y agoIt's fundamentally different to a nuclear engineer, but we still face an uncertain potential of fire, explosion, and radioactive contamination. To any of the thousands who are evacuating, especially farmers, it probably seems like a distinction without a difference at this point.
- mseebach 16y agoAnd striving for accuracy and consulting domain experts is a bad thing since when? And if significant technological differences doesn't interest you, here's a political one: People have actually been evacuated, even though the Japanese government claimed no risk at the time of doing so. Even if these people lose their homes and farms, and no-one can return to the region for 50 years, they still have their lives and health.
- VladRussian 16y ago>What I have seen is a huge number of media outlets and bloggers falling over themselves to assure everyone that everyone is safe and everything is under control. the posture of calmness and thoughtfulness are now in fashion. Anyway, nobody can predict the outcome - too many variables, including human intervention which in itself is highly unpredictable and looks more like a "knee jerk reaction" than a planned for such a case strategy. >... putting water on the melting fuel rods. That puzzles me a bit - whenever they tell about the water on the melting rods they also mention that it causes the water to split into hydrogen and oxygen which mix causes these explosions. Water is also neutron moderator, so may be it thus lesser of evil...
- lutorm 16y agoThe dissociation of water only happens when you put water on something that's very hot. But the fuel rods need to be cooled somehow, so it's probably the least bad scenario is to take some hydrogen production to get the fuel rods down to a safe temperature where this doesn't happen. The alternative is to not cool them at all, which will lead to a meltdown. I don't think the moderation aspect is important currently. The reactor is shut down, and the neutron flux is already very low.
- marshray 16y agoIn the case of the reactors, they have control rods in place to inhibit the fission. For the spent fuel pools, hopefully the rods are spaced much farther apart. Conceivably they could boil away all their water and melt their steel fixture and recombine in the bottom of the pool drain. I doubt the Japanese would let that happen, but if things go much farther downhill it could turn into a suicide mission to do anything at that plant site. And that would be very sad.