4 ms·

The type of relationship is different, but the example still holds. Having a profile at all can and likely will be viewed as an indicator of intention to leave

The type of relationship is different, but the example still holds. Having a profile at all can and likely will be viewed as an indicator of intention to leave the current relationship for a new relationship. This was how it was viewed having a resume profile on sites like Monster and CareerBuilder before LinkedIn made it the norm to have a public resume. Time frame is also very important. Example, a user has been with the company for over a decade, but the product has only been around for a few years. Or if one of the "achievements" was a test that was added recently.

pmiller2 6y ago
I have a TripleByte profile. Am I job hunting? This is not a hypothetical. I really do have a profile.
- reitzensteinm 6y ago
  Not necessarily. But what if you didn't have one yesterday, but you do have one today? What if you have only worked for one employer since TripleByte was founded (2015)? What if the only place you've worked is a startup of which you're a cofounder? If you can't think of a way in which a privacy leak can have consequences, that doesn't mean there aren't any.
  - pmiller2 6y ago
    What if I have? How does that imply anything other than that I took a test?
    - seebs 6y ago
      In the sense of a logical implication which follows with full logical necessity: it doesn't. In the sense of a likely reason for someone to draw an inference: Most people do not specifically seek out excuses to take tests, and do so only because they want something that the test provides them with, such as access to a job-hunting platform. Most people who want access to a job-hunting platform want it because they are job-hunting or plan to be soon.
    - withdavidli 6y ago
      It's a known interviewing service. The implication by many would be that you took the test because you were interested in interviewing. Is there another big use case that I'm missing from their product? Interested in hearing your interpretation of a person that has a profile on an interviewing service. My assumption would be the main objective of a user signing up for a service would be using the main product the service provides.
    - haram_masala 6y ago
      After reading your various comments, I have to ask if you have any relationship with Triplebyte and/or its founders beyond merely using the service. And yes, I would greatly appreciate an answer to this.
      - pmiller2 6y ago
        I do not, other than having interviewed with them. For the record, I would not care to repeat the experience, either. I found the process unnecessarily stressful and not worth the time investment. Nonetheless, I don’t find very much wrong with what they do, in general, or what they’ve done here. Do you think because I have a dissenting opinion, I must necessarily be some kind of shill. Come out and say it, if so.
        haram_masala 6y ago
        I didn’t know one way or the other, which is why I asked. Perhaps the unspoken bias I’m putting on display is the assumption that no independent observer could possibly think their actions were ethical.
    - deleted 6y ago
      [deleted]

pmiller2 6y ago

I have a TripleByte profile. Am I job hunting? This is not a hypothetical. I really do have a profile.

reitzensteinm 6y ago
Not necessarily. But what if you didn't have one yesterday, but you do have one today? What if you have only worked for one employer since TripleByte was founded (2015)? What if the only place you've worked is a startup of which you're a cofounder? If you can't think of a way in which a privacy leak can have consequences, that doesn't mean there aren't any.
- pmiller2 6y ago
  What if I have? How does that imply anything other than that I took a test?
  - seebs 6y ago
    In the sense of a logical implication which follows with full logical necessity: it doesn't. In the sense of a likely reason for someone to draw an inference: Most people do not specifically seek out excuses to take tests, and do so only because they want something that the test provides them with, such as access to a job-hunting platform. Most people who want access to a job-hunting platform want it because they are job-hunting or plan to be soon.
  - withdavidli 6y ago
    It's a known interviewing service. The implication by many would be that you took the test because you were interested in interviewing. Is there another big use case that I'm missing from their product? Interested in hearing your interpretation of a person that has a profile on an interviewing service. My assumption would be the main objective of a user signing up for a service would be using the main product the service provides.
  - haram_masala 6y ago
    After reading your various comments, I have to ask if you have any relationship with Triplebyte and/or its founders beyond merely using the service. And yes, I would greatly appreciate an answer to this.
    - pmiller2 6y ago
      I do not, other than having interviewed with them. For the record, I would not care to repeat the experience, either. I found the process unnecessarily stressful and not worth the time investment. Nonetheless, I don’t find very much wrong with what they do, in general, or what they’ve done here. Do you think because I have a dissenting opinion, I must necessarily be some kind of shill. Come out and say it, if so.
      - haram_masala 6y ago
        I didn’t know one way or the other, which is why I asked. Perhaps the unspoken bias I’m putting on display is the assumption that no independent observer could possibly think their actions were ethical.
  - deleted 6y ago
    [deleted]