8 ms·
Time Warner Cable trying to make municipal fiber illegal in North Carolina
- retroafroman 16y agoBe sure to read to the end and see the update at the bottom where he mentions that he has received grants from Time Warner Cable (the ISP here in NC). I agree with some of the statements, we shouldn't have municipal fiber networks where it doesn't make sense. On the other hand, I've had stellar experience with locally owned and operated broadband networks in other states, and I don't think we need a bill to make that illegal. A few bad examples doesn't mean we need a law to prohibit it in the future.
- jerf 16y ago"I don't think we need a bill to make that illegal." It doesn't sound like this makes it illegal. It sounds like it makes it illegal for municipalities to engage in anticompetitive practices, or what we'd call anticompetitive practices if they weren't a government. That's not the same thing. I have no opinion on the bill itself. I found the article thought-provoking, but being libertarian I'm still inclined to say that a municipality shouldn't be running a business like that. Not even because it'll give bad service to the customers necessarily, but also because a municipality just shouldn't have to deal with a case where it builds out millions of dollars of infrastructure and then can't recoup the costs because its business analysis was crappy. Society has solid, tested mechanisms for dealing with that when companies go wrong and have to go under, it's a lot harder for a municipality. They shouldn't be engaging in that sort of risky behavior, even as I'm not sure I want to ban it.
- _delirium 16y agoGiven that this sort of infrastructure tends to be a natural monopoly or close to one, it seems like a perfect case for either the government to build it, or some sort of quasi-governmental regulated utility, the same way power lines are operated. If you consider it an actual utility, the government is implicitly going to be guaranteeing it one way or another, because people aren't going to be willing to put up with a company going bankrupt resulting in service just being discontinued. Even in states where energy production is free-market/deregulated, with consumers choosing which power generators to buy from at market rates, the actual lines over which the power flows are either government-owned or quasi-governmental, because competition for provision of power lines doesn't work particularly well. Regardless of the pros/cons though, municipal experimentation in this area seems the least problematic to me. If the federal government or even a state is doing something, it's hard to escape and covers a large area. If a town is doing something, and people don't like it, it's much easier to just avoid that town. If some strategies clearly end up working much better than others, we'll be able to see which towns succeed in their strategies and which fail. Municipalities are also somewhat more constrained in their ability to waste unlimited taxpayer money, due to a mixture of fewer taxes they're allowed to levy, and the fact that people can just move to another town if things get too onerous.
- jerf 16y agoBuilding power lines isn't the same level of risk. What's the probability a given house wants power? Basically 100%. Municipalities have lost their metaphorical shirts on fibre rollouts before. If it was similar in all relevant ways you wouldn't have such different outcomes. That's a sign your argument isn't capturing something about reality. The reason why I'm not in a hurry to ban it is that I'm actually not upset to see people experience the consequences of their actions. It inevitably happens anyhow and trying to legislate it away has the usual problems that arise when you try to legislate an impossibility. I suppose I shouldn't have used the dreaded l-word; we say nearly the same thing but you wouldn't know it from the karma outcome.
- IgorPartola 16y agoI was under the impression that telephone lines were considered utility infrastructure and not everyone wants a land line (or ever did).
- retroafroman 16y agoI agree that we probably shouldn't have communities running anticompetitive businesses, but as you say, I don't want to ban it. Also, if some community does decide run their own network, does this bill mean they can't use government grants to set it up and get it started before becoming profitable? That may effectually make getting these sort of community broadband plans impossible to start in the future.
- lukeschlather 16y agoMunicipalities, by definition, engage in anticompetitive practices. Electricity, garbage, sewer, water. For utilities, the municipality is the arbiter of who gets to provide them. Often it does them itself. There's no reason Internet should be any different. Furthermore, there are a lot of reasons Internet should be exactly the same.
- iwwr 16y agoThere's one thing to be offering these services but another thing to ban competition in the same areas. Even worse, the monopoly is justified in the name of 'natural monopoly', yet there is still the need to legislate this monopoly (as if nature needed any encouragement). Furthermore, as soon as you get a local monopoly on internet access, you are only one city council decision away from local censorship. After all, he who pays gets to call the shots ("Porn on the tax-paid internet? No way! Think of the children.")
- jellicle 16y ago> There's one thing to be offering these services but another thing to ban competition in the same areas. You are aware that this article is about a bill, written by Time-Warner, to ban municipalities from competing with them, right?
- leot 16y agoWhy can't a group of people decide what they want for themselves democratically? Why not let municipalities be free to provide internet as a utility (like roads, electricity, etc.)? After all, this doesn't mean they all have to do so.
- robflynn 16y agoI am originally from rural North Carolina and happen to be visiting my parents at the moment. I'll give a quick run-down of their internet options over the years: From 1995-2000, their only option was dialup. 56k dialup was offered but the quality of the phone lines in the area only allowed for 26k - 28k at best. Sometime around 2000 or 2001, "broadband" finally moved to the area. However, they can not get DSL or Cable. They have a wireless ISP (radio installed on the house, receives signal from a tower.) They get about 1mpbs down and about 10% packet loss. Last night I was battling 35% packet loss while trying to do some work. Parts of the county do have DSL and Cable. A guy who lives about 10 houses up from my dad has Time Warner broadband. He's had it for 10 years and loves it. My parent's can't get it, however, because they're just over the county line and apparently this county has some sort of exclusivity agreement with another small/local cable company. That small cable company does have broadband, but only to small/select area of the county, and they don't seem to have any interest in heading out this way. I really don't even know what to do to help them anymore as far as connectivity goes. I just know that it annoys them. Anyway, the point of my little tirade is: It angers me to see possible additional imposed limitations to an area which already struggles to have anything to begin with.
- cygwin98 16y agoIf it were me in this situation, I would talk to the guy who has the cable and share his connection (even pay for his monthly fee to provide incentive). It's relatively easy to connect two houses by using directional wireless antenna.
- robflynn 16y agoWe considered that, actually. I need to look into it a bit more for them. The guy lives about 1/2 mile away and there's quite a bit of trees in the way.
- tdoggette 16y agoDepending on how determined you are, 900mhz is unlicensed and can punch a wireless signal through trees. Equipment can be expensive, but there's surplus stuff out there, esp. among hams. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/33-centimeter_band http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/33-centimeter_band
- js2 16y agoI live in the triangle area. My broadband options are limited. An excerpt I wrote nominating my municipality for Google Fiber for Communities: Though there are many technology workers here, the area has limited Internet access providers, primarily BellSouth DSL and Time Warner cable, both of which have higher prices, yet offer less bandwidth compated to providers in other regions. For example, Comcast advertises (in Santa Clara, CA) 15 Mbps down, 3 Mbps up (w/PowerBoost) for $42.95 per month, after a six-month intro of $19.99. By comparison, Time Warner Cable offers only 10 Mbps down, 512 Kbps up for $64.90 per month, after a six-month intro of $39.90/month. Two-thirds the bandwidth for 1.5x the cost, nevermind that I can't even get higher speed if I wanted to. DSL is even worse. I can't get BellSouth's website to tell me what DSL options are available at my address, but att.com advertises 6 Mbps DSL for $42.95 per month after a 12-month intro of $24.95. AT&T U-verse is not yet available to me either. Now look what Wilson, NC, 60 miles to the east, offers to its residents: http://www.greenlightnc.com/about/internet/ http://www.greenlightnc.com/about/internet/ 10 Mbps symmetric service for $35/month up to 100 Mbps symmetric for $150/month. More about what's going on at http://savencbb.wordpress.com/ http://savencbb.wordpress.com/
- robflynn 16y ago(sigh) I guess I need to move to Wilmington (or back to CA.) A fellow HNer/friend mentioned this: https://epbfi.com/internet/ https://epbfi.com/internet/ Chattanooga TN offering 1gbps service for $350/mo.
- robterrell 16y agoThe article focuses on two cities that bought out their failing local providers. Considering that they were failing, it's probably no surprise that city managers with no experience in that business can't run them any better. The article completely ignores Greenlight (http://www.greenlightnc.com/ http://www.greenlightnc.com/) -- the successful municipal broadband network in Wilson, NC that has been battling TW in the courts. To me, it appears the bill is aimed directly at Greenlight. BTW I live in Raleigh, I pay TWC $105 per month for business class service: 10/2 with 5 static IPs. (I get roughly 7/1. They won't prorate for the missing bits.)
- mseebach 16y agoIs Greenlight profitable on its own (including capital costs), or is it subsidized?
- jellicle 16y agoWhy would that matter? Are roads profitable on their own (including capital costs), or are they subsidized?
- IgorPartola 16y agoDon't have the link handy, but just today I read that Greenlight is not yet profitable, but is on its way to be so. Consider that the fiber that's now in the ground is a really long term investment: it can last for at least the next 20 years and maybe even longer.
- mseebach 16y agoThe headline is not just editorializing heavily, it's plain wrong. [The bill] seeks to ensure that cities, who function in the dual role of regulator and competitor in such markets, don’t abuse their regulatory power to privilege themselves with respect to their competitors. [...] The bills require municipal broadband operators play by the same rules and regulations that apply to commercial operators, to refrain from cross-subsidizing their networks by raiding other kitties, to price at cost or above, and to allow fair access to rights of way. Say what you want about Time Warner being out there, pushing any bill, but let's at least judge the bill by it's actual content.
- gergles 16y agoSo, you're relying on the editorialized summary of the legislation instead of the actual text to call the article "wrong"? Municipal broadband operators shouldn't have to "play fair". Broadband access is a natural monopoly, and a municipality offering quality service should not be bound by the same obligations as a profit-making enterprise. If the city and its residents believe that broadband is worth funding, via any method they choose to do so, that should absolutely be their right regardless of what TWC and their lobbyists think.
- mseebach 16y agoNo, I'm relying on the linked article to conclude that the headline linking to that article doesn't accurate reflect the content of the article, in fact it editorializes it. Both are contrary to HN guidelines. The fact that you agree with the editorializing is irrelevant.
- protomyth 16y agoor you could go read the bill at http://www.ncga.state.nc.us/Sessions/2011/Bills/House/PDF/H129v0.pdf http://www.ncga.state.nc.us/Sessions/2011/Bills/House/PDF/H1... It basically stops a community from providing broadband as part of the basic city services (like fire, police).
- 5teev 16y ago
- runjake 16y agoI can't be bothered to read this article, I'll get too angry. I have no clue about this particular case, but I've been involved in other municipal fiber projects, and big telcos (plural, not just one) routinely tried to stop or sabotage these projects, often surreptitiously. As far as they're concerned, you're encroaching on their territory. It's complete crap. It happens all over the country. A commenter below mentions that they thought the headline was editorialized heavily or plain wrong. Again, I have no clue about this particular case, but these corporations work in underhanded ways.
- tomsaffell 16y agoIt's a shame you can't be bothered to read it. It's an even greater shame that the comment at the top of the page was written by a person who didn't read the article.
- Lost_BiomedE 16y agoI know this too well. Telcos also locked out DSL providers from their own DSLAMs to cripple competition. FCC response, in the end, was that monopolies were O.K. if there were two technologies, a 'duopoly' of DSL and Cable.
- nhangen 16y agoTime Warner is probably the worst cable service provider I've ever used in my life. I was so happy to move to Florida and get Verizon at 30/30 for the same price I paid for Time Warner's poor quality and consistently dropped service. As for the bill itself - I don't see why any regulatory body or bill should tell a business how much they can charge, government or otherwise.
- IgorPartola 16y agoSome more background: http://www.wxii12.com/money/27123939/detail.html http://www.wxii12.com/money/27123939/detail.html http://www.techjournalsouth.com/2009/04/nc-considering-bill-to-limit-municipal-broadband-efforts/ http://www.techjournalsouth.com/2009/04/nc-considering-bill-... http://www.examiner.com/technology-in-raleigh/raleigh-city-council-adopts-resolutionagainst-limiting-municipal-broadband-1 http://www.examiner.com/technology-in-raleigh/raleigh-city-c...
- dylanrw 16y agoI spoke at length with my Representative about this several weeks back and he was on the fence. He does not want to see Government compete directly with private corps, but in this case I would argue that the internet is a core utility like water/power, especially if you expect growth in high paying tech jobs in an area. This is an example of old world thinking/planning being played by the savvy private interests, and it is alarming.
- jsz0 16y agoIt's a horrendous thing for consumers but let's remember municipalities lured in cable companies to build in rural areas by promising little or no competition via exclusive franchising agreements. The municipalities usually get a small cut of profits from the cable provider as well. Blame TWC but also blame the municipality itself for 20-30 years of anti-competitive behavior and the voters who allow this to happen. If this passes it will be entirely consistent with the history of cable franchises. In the end this may all be a show to get a higher kick-back out of TWC.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoIf the government wants our data usage records, today we have at least a hope that our (corporate) ISP will protect our privacy, at least until the government comes up with a subpeona. If the government is our ISP, do we have any hope of avoiding the scrutiny of government?
- hartror 16y agoYou trust corporates more than you trust the government? At least the government is in theory suppose to look after your best interests, corporations have no such requirement. Either way the best solution is maintaining strict privacy laws with monitoring and oversight by the free press and well funded and respected organisations such as a better funded EFF.