4 ms·
I've seen a bunch of these arguments recently, and they seem pretty baffling to me. It's not "rigging", it's supply and demand, nothing more. As an employee com
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I've seen a bunch of these arguments recently, and they seem pretty baffling to me. It's not "rigging", it's supply and demand, nothing more. As an employee competing against other potential employers, you're going to demand a rate of pay that you think is "worth it" to you. The issue is, many people would be willing to work for less if they could stretch those dollars further in a lower cost locale.
I've generally been a fan of Greenspun's blog, but this conclusion seems nonsensical to me.
- matthewbauer 6y agoI don’t think this is quite supply and demand. The remote worker is already hired and then they move. The value Facebook gets presumably hasn’t changed but they are now paying a different rate. If this were about starting salaries, you might be right.
- mstibbard 6y agoI'd assume they would keep total cost to Facebook roughly similar, which depending on the state you move to it might result in less take home pay for the employee?
- phreeza 6y agoHow so, the same argument about making dollars go further applies to someone already hired.
- toto444 6y agoFacebook employees working in London are paid, say, half as much as the ones in SV. If we follow your reasoning, London employees are half as productive as the SV ones.
- SauciestGNU 6y agoIf I knew my colleague in the same position as me was making twice as much as I do just by virtue of physical location, I'd be pretty miffed. I probably won't work at much more than half capacity, if even that much.
- BorisTheBrave 6y agoSupply and demand makes sense as an explanation in a lot of these cases, but it doesn't actually explain this one. If facebook were just charging a market rate determined by supply and demand, then your salary would drop when you become remote, regardless of where you actually live, as your location has nearly no bearing on your productivity or competition for the same job. The fact that Facebook wants workers to report their location, as they cannot easily see the difference, shows their motivation cannot be driven by supply and demand.
- joshuamorton 6y agoThis doesn't actually follow. Assume that there is a wide degree of variation in what people value "living in San Francisco" at. Some people value it at a million dollars a year, others value it negatively (ie. they'd prefer, all else equal, to live in Kansas). Both of these people probably exist in the real world. If it costs N$ to purchase one developer in Kansas, and $2N to purchase on developer in SF, if there are enough developers in Kansas to satisfy the demand, then yes the price drops to $N. But if in fact the demand is higher than the supply Kansas can provide, then Facebook will buy out Kansas, and get its remaining supply from SF. The average price of developers goes down, yes, but you get a form of price discrimination since those in SF value the city at more than the increase in relative salary from leaving. The Kansas developers could increase their cost to compensate, sure, but you run into a few issues, while the market is supply-limited otherwise this wouldn't be an issue, if Kansas devs cost the same as SF devs, FB might just revert to its old practice and leave the Kansas devs back jobless. You can sort of think of this as high CoL cities having a monopoly effect on pricing. "Normally" the market would fix this, but people are attracted to cities for lifestyle perks that can't be made up with equivalent $$. In other words, the city has an absolute advantage in city-lifestyle, so others can't compete on price to people who want city-lifestyle. In other words, for the person who enjoys living in SF, you'd have to offer them more to work in Kansas than to work in SF. As long as enough of those people exist, the market won't equalize. The normal econ-101 kind of understanding of supply and demand doesn't work, because you have, in essence, one consumer who wishes to purchase from two different markets with different market prices. City-livers and non-city-livers.
- boublepop 6y agoYou don’t see food costs in Walmart adjusted based on you income, even though supply and demand would also dictate that you’d be willing to pay more for milk if you have a higher income. It’s not supply and demand to allow once side to differentiate costs based on factors that shouldn’t matter to them, that’s rigging the system.
- Balgair 6y agoNit: Food Stamps affect this a fair bit. ~10% of Walmart's gross income comes from food stamps (SNAP). https://www.huffpost.com/entry/walmart-food-stamps_n_4181862 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/walmart-food-stamps_n_4181862 https://www.statista.com/statistics/223080/government-spending-for-snap-benefits/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/223080/government-spendi... https://www.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/wmt/financials https://www.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/wmt/financials
- perl4ever 6y agoI think you underestimate the amount of price discrimination that is possible and practiced in grocery stores. And how much it matters. Any trade normally creates value, but that doesn't mean the two sides each capture half of that value. The whole business of business is trying to make sure 99% of it goes to them and not the consumer. Coupons are one obvious long-standing mechanism. Loyalty cards are another. Another is the stocking of similar products at different price points in different locations, either different stores or different places within a store. Many stores these days seem not only to have a store brand vs. brand name products, but may have two or more levels of store or economy brands. You can add products from local producers at a higher price; maybe they even come from the same source as the regular ones, but you label them to differentiate your customers. Yet another thing I've seen (granted, it could be an error, but who knows) is pricing a larger size product or one that is labeled as an "economy" size at a higher per-unit cost than a smaller one. Or even pricing it at the same per-unit cost, which helps extract more money from people. The basic principle you use to discriminate when you can't do it directly is to exploit a correlation - an obvious way to charge people with money more is to use the fact that they probably value their time more and are more impatient. But if someone who is poor is impatient, and is stuck paying more, all the better for the business. People are far from ideal economically rational actors and every aspect where it's normal to use heuristics can be targeted to improve profits.
- Balgair 6y agoAlso, FB's potential employee base is larger now. Folks that wouldn't move to SV proper but are in Bakersfield or Truckee can now be in that programming base. Increased supply of workers means that prices/salaries will drop, likely.