4 ms·
I got a takedown notice on YouTube for posting a chamber music recording of me and 3 friends playing a piece written in 1715. Insane. We need to work on AI tha
by bcatanzaro 6y ago
I got a takedown notice on YouTube for posting a chamber music recording of me and 3 friends playing a piece written in 1715. Insane.
We need to work on AI that can evaluate the musical talent in a recording. I mean yes, I was playing the same song as some famous musician, but anyone could tell I am an amateur and my recording was not professional.
- nitrogen 6y agoWe need to work on AI that can evaluate the musical talent in a recording. I mean yes, I was playing the same song as some famous musician, but anyone could tell I am an amateur and my recording was not professional. Years of reading the arguments on HN (and other forums and aggregators before that) have convinced me that technology will not provide the answers to this problem. We need better laws from governments, and better policies from corporations.
- ngold 6y agoHow about every copyright claim has to be submitted in a handwritten letter with a picture of you holding that days newspaper. Then put the photo and handwritten note in an envelope and mail it in.
- kec 6y agoBetter (and simpler), there needs to be a fine or other punishment for fraudulent copyright claims. Even better if that fine can be proportional to income of the claimant.
- 0x00000000 6y agoOr the fine is that the work in question becomes public domain.
- kube-system 6y agoThese YouTube takedowns are typically not copyright claims. The DMCA process does have more rigor. YouTube has a voluntary process that doesn’t require any of that rigor. YouTube’s company policy is essentially “ask us and we’ll take it down”, and has nothing to do with what the law requires.