3 ms·
> I personally think that people pushing against standardized tests and for holistic admissions have good intentions and aren't trying to systemically ensure th
by rayiner 7y ago
> I personally think that people pushing against standardized tests and for holistic admissions have good intentions and aren't trying to systemically ensure that all students at prestigious and elite universities in the US talk, think, and act like them, but I can't blame anyone for thinking so.
I’m not sure I feel like giving the benefit of the doubt here. I think folks are acting in good faith, no doubt. But they have decided that everyone who doesn’t talk, think, and act like them is a danger to society. Where those people are white, they can be condemned as “deplorables.” Where those same views are shared by minorities (Asian Americans with respect to views on family and marriage, and meritocracy, black people with respect to views on religion, etc.) they just select figureheads that happen to agree with them and then have those people claim to speak for everyone non-white.
- hooande 7y agosome ideas are dangerous to society, flat out. ie, "the institution of slavery was good because it's part of my cultural heritage". University admissions are not just an issue of personal merit. It isn't something that you're owed because you did X, Y and Z. Colleges are trying to build a positive culture, just like startups, and that can involve rejecting skilled people with fringe beliefs. Not to mention, who wants to pay $30,000/yr and have their kid be roommates with a holocaust denier? People can believe whatever they want. They just can't work and go to school wherever they want