3 ms·
Because the earnings part comes before the tax part, which is the proper order of operations. In order to produce earnings, our system dictates that you do some
by chrisco255 6y ago
Because the earnings part comes before the tax part, which is the proper order of operations. In order to produce earnings, our system dictates that you do something economically useful. That's not a perfect system, but it has produced the modern economy and for all its flaws, no economy in history has produced as much wealth as exists today.
I am highly skeptical of UBI. The U.S. is the last place that should try it, it should be experimented on in a country like New Zealand or Italy... not on an economy like the U.S., which could bring down world trade if UBI ends in economic catastrophe, such as hyperinflation, which is a very real possibility.
- vkou 6y ago> Because the earnings part comes before the tax part, which is the proper order of operations. In order to produce earnings, our system dictates that you do something economically useful. That's not a perfect system, but it has produced the modern economy and for all its flaws, no economy in history has produced as much wealth as exists today. It should be noted that if it weren't for the energy we are extracting from fossil fuels, we'd all be subsistence peasants eating mud, and shoveling cow shit with our hands for a living. The economic system is a rounding error, compared to the colossal increase in wealth unlocked by cheap access to energy.
- malandrew 6y agocheap access to energy is merely a lever for allowing people to be even more economically useful. By itself, cheap access to energy is worth nothing.
- jdale27 6y agoThe economic system enabled the extraction of fossil fuels in the first place. Capitalism predates the industrial revolution.
- vkou 6y agoNon-capitalist societies that industrialized also saw enormous gains in wealth. The difference between the US and the USSR was much smaller than the difference between pre-industrialized Russia, and the USSR.
- chrisco255 6y agoIn what decade? By the 1980s, the U.S. had far outstripped the U.S.S.R. in economic performance by every single measure. Here's some clips of a Soviet grocery store: http://www.strangehistory.net/2017/08/11/joys-supermarket-shopping-soviet-union/ http://www.strangehistory.net/2017/08/11/joys-supermarket-sh...
- chillacy 6y agoI see UBI as more of a response to the existing conditional welfare system which already exists and circumvents this system in the most perverse way where you can make _more_ money on disability than doing something economically useful. At least with UBI you can eliminate these incentive gaps. Doesn't have to be UBI either, a NIT could do the same thing, maybe even the EITC as long as it keeps the earning curve monotonic.
- sdenton4 6y agoAs Henry Ford said, cars will never go anywhere, because, for all their flaws, no mode of transportation in history has been more efficient than the train.
- chrisco255 6y agoIf you think welfare or government handouts are some new technology that's going to usher in a new era, I've got some history books for you to read.
- vinceguidry 6y agoI would LOVE to see more US experiments with UBI. The economics have already been tested. The federal government has these enormous funded installations where the people living there don't have to worry about the economy at all. These gov-funded individuals then go and spend their largesse in the local economy, in many cases propping them up all by themselves. This happens on a massive scale, right here, right now. They're called military bases. Politicians lobby hard to get the federal government to build them in their states, whether they're needed for military purposes or not. People pooh-poohing UBI just don't seem to understand just how much of the economy already is paying people to do not much that is actually useful. So many of us have bullshit jobs. There would be mass poverty and unemployment otherwise. Formalizing it instead of hiding it behind a veneer of fake usefulness will allow us to study it. Companies will have to entice people to take jobs rather than coerce them. It'll be amazing.
- chrisco255 6y agoBullshit jobs? Like which ones exactly? Who determines which ones are bullshit and which ones are not? We don't just create jobs for nothing. Companies that hire excess employees tend to go out of business or shed workers during a downturn like we're experiencing now. In the meantime, no, we had a thriving restaurant and travel industry 2 months ago but the fact those people have been laid off or furloughed doesn't mean their jobs were bullshit. It's never been tried at a macro scale for an extended period of time. You are being recklessly ignorant of the very real economic risks. Spending trillions more on top of the trillions in deficits we already have, but making those deficits permanent and ongoing with no ability to pay down will cause rapid inflation that could very easily evolve to hyper inflation like happened in the Weimar Republic in Germany in the 1920s and like has happened more recently in Venezuela and Zimbabwe. We may get there without UBI based on current trajectories, but UBI will just usher it in all the more quickly.
- vinceguidry 6y ago> Like which ones exactly? Who determines which ones are bullshit and which ones are not? The market would, once one gets empowered to be created. Right now the market is tipped on the side of those offering money for work. If you truly flipped the tables around, then those offering money have to offer more and more and more. I'm not just talking money here but all those intangibles that make one job better than another.