12 ms·
> What is it about tech culture that people within it refuse to admit the level of abuse-by-design that happens at these companies? The Amazon example is extre
by MattGaiser 6y ago
> What is it about tech culture that people within it refuse to admit the level of abuse-by-design that happens at these companies?
The Amazon example is extreme, but a lot of tech workers fit the stereotype of people who don't have a lot else to do.
I spend 100+ hours at my computer a week, so if you want long hours, I can live with that.
I am up at 1AM anyway, so if you need something done at that time, sure. I just need to switch to my remote desktop.
I have colleagues and friends who will log in on weekends or evenings out of boredom to do work. No pressure to do it, but they just want something to do.
I fill my time with internet commenting and various online contests, but if they need help at 9PM, I am fine with jumping on the VPN to help and have done that a few times myself.
Amazon still has problems beyond the long hours and the 3AM calls, but there are people ok with those things or at least ok enough with them to not put up a fuss.
- troughway 6y ago>The Amazon example is extreme, but a lot of tech workers fit the stereotype of people who don't have a lot else to do. Very sad when you think about it. Wasted potential.
- MattGaiser 6y ago> Very sad when you think about it. Wasted potential. Eh, you leave the university environment of all its clubs, hackathons, etc, likely to another city where you know far fewer people. You need to wake up the next morning, so gaming until 5AM with your friends no longer works. Someone is also on on-call, so they can't join, so you postpose it further. The end result is a lot more free time.
- SamuelAdams 6y agoMaybe it's just the type of people amazon hires? I've been programming for 5+ years. Know what I'm doing today at 5 pm? Headed over to Lake Michigan with the fiance. Yesterday I went on a 4 mile run. Personally I never check things outside of 8-5 and my employer is A-OK with that. The biggest problem is when people like this article's author get a job and the HR people never make it clear that they may need to have "pager duty" or otherwise work outside of 8-5. Those different expectations is what caused him to have a very bad experience.
- MattGaiser 6y ago> never make it clear that they may need to have "pager duty" or otherwise work outside of 8-5. Yes, these expectations should be made clear from the beginning. I suspect they don't as they would be even more desperate to hire.
- notyourwork 6y agoAmazon is open about engineers owning their on-call duty. This should not be a surprise to a new hire.
- ladrien 6y agoIdiot
- dang 6y agoPersonal attacks and name-calling are bannable offenses here. Would you mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and sticking to the rules when posting to HN? We'd be grateful.
- notyourwork 6y agoI’m not sure what in my comment offended you. Sorry.
- rootusrootus 6y agoOne thing seems to have changed since the OP wrote their post -- managers at AWS are open about the on-call requirement. At least the ones in Portland. They were proud that they owned the product all the way from the code on the back to the customer at the front. So if you didn't want to be responsible for some level of ops, you knew that going in. I didn't move forward to an interview, this was just from a meet-and-greet they did a few months ago (they do it every month IIRC). I have other reasons for not being at all interested in working for Amazon, but I figured it would be interesting to meet with them informally anyway.
- bananamerica 6y agoMaybe they need hobbies that are actually relaxing and not side projects.
- ebg13 6y agoThey can't because of hustle culture.
- joenot443 6y agoI do believe there are people out there for whom "living their best life" truly does entail spending almost all their time in front of a computer. Nobody shamed Chopin for spending his life in front of the piano. Some people choose to dedicate their lives to one single thing, and often those are the people who end up contributing the most.
- bananamerica 6y agoMaybe Chopin took long walks in the garden every once in an while. And maybe, just maybe, universally acclaimed musical geniuses are not a good point of comparison for common folk.
- falafel 6y agoThat's not the comparison as far as I understand it. The analogy is of someone that dedicates all their time to becoming the best at their craft, like Chopin. It's not about being a genius.
- cafard 6y agoHell, he ran off to Mallorca with George Sand. My impression is that composers work intensely, but manage to find time to do other things.
- rantwasp 6y agoyeah no. as someone who has worked at Amazon for 7 years I can tell you that it’s not true across the board and there are good “pockets” where there is respect for people’s boundaries. To add to this, in my time there I worked during the weekend 3 times (i don’t count oncall here). My work day included 8 hours at most. I would get in at around 8AM and leave at 4PM. (optimizing the commute) I started as an SDE 2 by the time I left I was a Principal SDE. Do good work, be in a good org. Amazon is not a huge, homogeneous entity. It’s more like hundreds of small companies that are forced to work together, bound together by senior leadership.
- MattGaiser 6y agoI am sure it is not all of Amazon, but that is where the horror stories are coming from. So Amazon as a whole may not have this culture, but the teams with this culture seem to disproportionately be at Amazon.
- rantwasp 6y agoso, the bigger an org, the higher the likelihood of stories like this popping up. also, the incentives and their structure play a part in how this unfolds. It’s also very curious to me that only a certain type of person runs into situations like these: either they don’t know better or they have accepted the conditioning that work is more important than themselves. it’s sad really. i think it’s really really important to have a good mentor with a strong set of values to help you navigate the corporate landscape. i also think it’s important to pull a Ghandi (ie be the change you want to see) as often as possible. for example: one think i would inoculate in young devs is that it’s not acceptable to set meetings earlier than 9am or later than 4pm. meetings during lunch were not accepted. i would be pretty vocal about morons that worked over the weekend because they had some free time. i would also push really hard against management that had their sick little practices to extract more work out of the drones. this mostly worked because i got the job done - but again: you have a voice. you are NOT a machine
- bobthepanda 6y agolaw of numbers; Amazon Seattle headcount alone is 50K+ people. also, amazon has a service-oriented management model to match the general SoA architecture, where small teams are given massive leeway as to how exactly they run their services. managers and your leadership are thus very make or break.
- thorwasdfasdf 6y agothis is very informative. I wouldn't have believed it, without the first person perspective. Before i read this, it was simply unbelievable to me that people could be that bored without any life outside work. Speaking as someone who really values free time and has tons of hobbies and things to do outside of work, it's just unbelievable.
- MattGaiser 6y agoMost of the people I know are fairly new graduates, so that would skew things. My friends and I spent most of our lives since grade 9 doing school stuff or stuff to get into school stuff. In my case, couple that with introversion and an aversion to most normal activities and the easiest thing to do is be good at the get into school stuff. In university, most of my social activities revolved around the startup world, hackathons, or other competition-oriented activities as that is what I was good at. I went to one hackathon a weekend in my final academic year. So I became good at a lot of these types of things which all revolved around the academic world. I am not in university anymore, but I can still fill my time with the kinds of competitions and challenges in that world. If I couldn't, I doubt that I would know how to use my time. Even with those, I spend a ton of time commenting online. Most of the people I know are in the same kind of boat. They were good at one or two things (might be science fair, research, conference organizing, etc) back in university which consumed their time. Then they left and are now left wondering, "now what?"
- posix_me_less 6y agoThank you for sharing. I can hear a shy cry for help. I think it's fine to spend a lot of time with computer, in general, I do it myself. There is so much to do, learn and help others. On the other hand, I think it is good to realize when it eventually becomes a replacement activity for lack of motivation/opportunities to do something harder. Then try to break that, take a challenge, do something new, either with computer (a personal project to make something cool?) or better, without it - for example, try some manual work with wood, do some science project with a friend, or get a pet and teach him tricks or something. Just don't spend yourself fully on the online/academic life, that sounds too ephemeral and can be a bit disappointing later on. I for sure regret spending so much time in academia.