4 ms·
Has the AI gotten any better? Civilization has never been a bastion of great computer opponent strategy, but it typically was good enough to suspend disbelief
by duxup 7y ago
Has the AI gotten any better?
Civilization has never been a bastion of great computer opponent strategy, but it typically was good enough to suspend disbelief and enjoy. However, VI was just horrific. I played a lot of VI and stuck with it for a few years but the AI still would declare war... not attack, put little to no effort into defense.
It was a fun game and I got my value out of it but eventually it just became frustrating with the AI sort of rage quits and almost behaves like a human greifer just taking random actions that make no sense at all / kill the fun of the game.
I've played civ games constantly since civ but unlike the previous games I just had to quit VI because the AI made it seem so pointless when it ruins a perfectly good game by just going bonkers after you've put hours into it...
Unless it has gotten better, if you have a low tolerance for wonky AI, you might want to pass on this one.
- pyrophane 7y agoNo, it hasn't. The only way to really make the game challenging is to heap bonuses on the AI player, which is what the game does at higher difficulty levels.
- fastball 7y agoYou'd think at this point it would be worthwhile to use ML to train your AI for basically every big name game. It's fairly clear that such methods can make computer players that are better than any human player, and once you have the net it would be pretty easy to have different level computers based purely on how many epochs the net is trained for.
- duxup 7y agoI wonder how much retraining you'd have to do for each patch and rule change. In Civ patch to patch how you value things / do things can change fairly dramatically. Not that you couldn't do it, I just wonder what that would look like.
- waterhouse 7y agoI imagine that's one of the benefits of ML as opposed to a program that embodies crystallized human knowledge and skill: when things change, you don't have to get a bunch of humans to rethink the implications and rework the program, you just do more training.
- ra1n85 7y agoThis, sadly, is so accurate. That, or the fact that as difficulty levels increase, the game just gives the AI opponents crude modifiers - they don't get smarter, they just get cheat codes.
- ng12 7y agoI would shell out money for DLC that just added good AI. Computer players are so important for a game with friendship-ending potential.
- anjc 7y ago> I played a lot of VI and stuck with it for a few years > It was a fun game and I got my value out of it > you might want to pass on this [game that I played for years which is temporarily free] ?
- duxup 7y agoI think other people may find it less worth their time than I did if they greatly value the AI behavior. Folks putting time into a game that takes a while to complete might take quite awhile before they realize AI rage quitting is pretty common.
- D13Fd 7y agoI had the same reaction to that comment. I bought Civ VI for the iPad for maybe $40. I played it for probably 80 hours total, and felt like I got my money’s worth. It’s hard to imagine the mindset where you play a game for “years” and then say it wasn’t worth the $50 or so it cost.
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoIt would be great to see some of the advances in deep reinforcement learning flow into game AIs.