3 ms·
The US's interest in Taiwan is part of a divide and conquer strategy. Nothing less, nothing more. The current political regime in mainland China is actually th
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
The US's interest in Taiwan is part of a divide and conquer strategy. Nothing less, nothing more.
The current political regime in mainland China is actually the best thing for the US and a transition to democracy would be bad because that would make reunification more likely, at least possible, and it would take away much of the arguments the US use against China.
If the nationalists had defeated the communists and the mainland and Taiwan had remained united, I doubt that the tensions between China and the US would be less than they currently are, for example, because these tensions are not caused by the political regime in Beijing, they are much more profound.
In any case, the US cannot realistically intervene militarily directly against China whatever happens.
- Robotbeat 7y agoThat’s pretty silly and unfounded. The US is happy to trade with Europe, which is overall more economically powerful than the US but is democratic.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThe US is happy to trade with China. Nothing to do with my 'silly' point, which is about geopolitics and the deeper causes of tensions.
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoEurope isn't a country. The US would strongly oppose political unification of Europe, if such a thing were ever in the cards.
- chaostheory 7y ago> If the nationalists had defeated the communists and the mainland and Taiwan had remained united, I doubt that the tensions between China and the US would be less than they currently are. I disagree, and this is a fun thought experiment. 1. The relationship would be a hybrid of the relationships that the US has with both Japan / South Korea and India. - China would be a friendly enough, export focused economy that's too large to be bullied by the US - It would historically have been a Cold War ally, giving it a larger edge over India 2. The West would have access to China's economy. 3. There would be less uncertainty about laws, helping the business climate. 4. Silicon Valley's crown would have been usurped 10 years ago or even far earlier. Why? Because China would have more personal freedoms and protections like with speech. Freedom of speech is instrumental to places like Silicon Valley where creativity is vital. Things like the adoption of the Internet would have been far earlier. 5. HK would have long been a shadow of itself. Shanghai would have taken its place far sooner. 6. While corruption would still be bad, it would be much better than present circumstances due to a free press and more transparency. 7. Tensions with Japan would be worse, due to freedom of speech and much earlier economic and technological rivalry 8. Chinese global economic influence and dominance would be much greater and would have happened much faster and earlier. 9. Chinese media such as TV shows and movies would be way more interesting instead of the boring period pieces or variety shows they keep cranking out today. 10. The male to female ratio would be almost equal due to more civil rights for women which leads to more economic opportunities for females We could go on what China could have been... the Asian equivalent of the US. This would be a cool TV series. Reminds of The Man in High Tower TV show.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThis ignores geopolitical realities and the Chinese struggle to do away with foreign aggression and a decadent trend over the last 3 centuries. I am not trying to dream up what China could have been. I am saying that the tensions between China and the West stem from a trend that is more profound that the current Chinese regime. For example I think that virtually everything China is criticised about in its geopolitical policies and actions would be unchanged with a different regime because these are not things dreamed up by the communists but are deeper both in historical terms and in geopolitical interests terms. The communist party itself is a product of these trends and this struggle, not the cause.
- chaostheory 7y agoI’m not sure what “geopolitical realities” I’m missing because the KMT was born from the same grandfather that sired the CCP, Sun Yatzen. Also, almost all of Asia has been either under the colonial yoke or sphere of influence yet they are still friendly to the West due to both political alignment and deeper economic integration. I feel that history better supports my argument than it does yours
- mytailorisrich 6y agoExactly, the KMT was born from the same struggle as the CCP, and their overall policies regarding China's territorial claims and place in the world are quite aligned because these really are aims of the Chinese people, not specific political parties. The tensions between China and the West result from China's rise, not from the CCP being in power. China is not more or less 'friendly' because of the CCP. They are simply asserting themselves, advancing their interests, and trying to right perceived historical wrongs. How 'friendly' countries are between each others (and China isn't really unfriendly) depends on their interests, not really on political regimes. Case in point: The US are extremely friendly with Saudi Arabia. 'friendly' in this context is pretty meaningless, but if you insist: Korea is 'friendly' (well half of it) with the West because it sees it in its interests in order to balance China (and Japan) and because as a small country there is no reason not to be friendly, plus there are American troops there to remind them. They were as 'friendly' under the military dictatorship. Japan is 'friendly' because it sees it in its interests (against Russia and China, especially during the cold war) and because it was not left a choice anyway. When Vietnam opens up to the US it is to balance China's rise. The US are quite happy with that although Vietnam's regime is very similar to China's. Why? shared interests again. China does not need to balance between the big guys and to stay on their good side in that way. It is one of the biggest guys, so it acts like the US do, and that is the root of the problem for the US. Hopefully this clarifies the "geopolitical realities". To think that if 2 countries are both democracies they will be 'friendly', or that if they aren't they won't be, is very naive, frankly.
- ericmay 7y agoI think the U.S. can certainly intervene, the question is whether or not it is worth it.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoCan starting WWIII ever be worth it? So, no, the US will not attack China directly, in the same way that China will not attack the US directly. Edit: Using 'intervene' in response to a comment on direct military intervention should be clarified if you don't mean exactly that...
- ericmay 7y agoIntervening doesn't have to mean attacking China directly.