4 ms·
>Can you point to the studies which suggest that the ability to write is a strongly selected genetic ability? You're confusing phenotype and genotype. The gene
by whatshisface 6y ago
>Can you point to the studies which suggest that the ability to write is a strongly selected genetic ability?
You're confusing phenotype and genotype. The genes for the ability to write include the ones for the citric acid cycle, which I think we can all agree is selected for. Nobody knows what mutations would be necessary to stop antinatalism from catching on, but natural selection will probably be able to find them. If the answer was "humans are now too dumb to talk about antinatalism," then that would happen, although something else could happen as well. (Maybe "humans now love kids way more than previous generations thought possible.")
>I just remember. The Cherokee language turned a completely illiterate culture into one with more per capita readers than the recently introduced English culture.
Yeah, so obviously whatever genes give people the ability to write, from the citric acid cycle to the mysterious neurological stuff, are selected for strongly enough to be fixed in a population that was separated for a long time. You're not really disagreeing with me... I'm saying that "writing genes" are selected for, potentially because of benefits unrelated to writing, and you're saying that the behavior of writing isn't selected for. Those two statements do not contradict.
- eesmith 6y agoYou wrote "strongly selected for as the ability to write". I don't think there was any strong selection for the ability to write. How do you know it wasn't a spandrel?