3 ms·
So... it's a payout to landowners?
by BurningFrog 6y ago
So... it's a payout to landowners?
- jacknews 6y agoexactly, what the heck
- Vysero 6y ago? I am confused by this remark.. here in the US farmers are some of the poorest people in the country. Their land is nothing more than a burden and they live at or near poverty levels.
- balfirevic 6y agoSurely they must be strictly better off than not owning any land?
- Vysero 6y agoYou think so? Have you ever tried farming before? It's a rough life, and they never make money; they live off subsidies. When you own land you have to care for it and that costs: money, time and a substantial amount of effort. Most farmers I know would love to sell, but there is no one willing/able to buy.
- balfirevic 6y agoCan they give it away? Can they let it go unmaintained?
- Vysero 6y agoIf you had a plot of land worth millions would you give it away? No, they can't let it go unmaintained that's illegal.
- balfirevic 6y ago>> Surely they must be strictly better off than not owning any land? > If you had a plot of land worth millions would you give it away? WTF is happening in this conversation.
- Vysero 6y agoWhat is happening is that your being naive. You are attempting to paint a colorful situation with black and white. This is not a boolean if statement. You're wondering why wouldn't these farmers just walk away from their farm? Well there are many reasons: It's been in their family for generations. It's all they know how to do. They have legal obligations. The land may be worth millions but if all the buyers are aware of the fact that it's not worth buying then all those $$'s just mean you can take another loan out against it; which is better than parting with it for nothing. How about instead of asking questions you go do some research. I am not a farmer I just know a lot of farmers and they all drive old shitty cars and can't afford to get pay for their mothers dialysis.
- enitihas 6y agoYou have to realize that vast majority of India farm land owners are small farmers (very very small compared to US farm sizes). In my town and villages, 2 acre would be considered a lot of land for a farmer, and I don't even know if there was anybody nearby with anything like 10 acres of land. Most farmers own very small pieces of land. The scheme in question will help these farmers and is a very good step for national food production. There are some states with somewhat more centralised farms, but the state mentioned by the article is not one. Large scale industrial farming is very rare in India outside of a few select areas.
- BurningFrog 6y agoSo the small landowners will get a little money. But also the big landowners will get a lot of money?