7 ms·
My purchase of a piece of software does not give that software provider carte blanche access to what I do with that software. Unless I explicitly give my approv
by falcolas 6y ago
My purchase of a piece of software does not give that software provider carte blanche access to what I do with that software. Unless I explicitly give my approval (opt in), exfiltration of information from my system is an ethical breach of my privacy if not a breach of data protection laws.
As for why this matters, you need only look at Hong Kong for that answer. And even here in the US, many large companies are kowtowing to the Chinese government and changing their products in the US to toe those lines.
- craftinator 6y agoI'd gladly agree to negotiate a sale of my usage data, where I can set my price and they can decide if they'd like to buy it. Or better, I'll agree to send my telemetry data if they agree to send me their source code so I can see exactly what is being sent.
- falcolas 6y agoI'm wholly in favor of an equitable exchange between consenting parties. Thumbs up from me.
- matthewbauer 6y agoThe "equitable exchange" of telemetry is you give anonymized usage data for free, and the developers provide you with a better product based on that data. If you trust the developer, it sounds like a reasonable deal to me. No one is making you use that software.
- falcolas 6y ago> the developers provide you with a better product based on that data I think that it's incorrect to believe that telemetry allows developers to build "better" software. Web pages have had intrusive telemetry for over a decade now, and they still broadly suck. We're able to navigate the world of hamburger menus, text with poor contrast, and scrolljacking because we're adaptable humans, not because these kinds of changes actually improve the websites. The problem is that telemetry can only tell you the "what" and "how", but not the "why". > If you trust the developer It's not just the developers who gain access to that data. It's everybody at the company. It's 3rd parties who contract with that company. It's everybody who hacks into the data set at the company. And it's every governmental agency from (almost) any country with an overly broad warrant who has access to that data. See my upstream comments about China and Hong Kong > No one is making you use that software. Just as nobody is making an effort to make it simple (or even possible) to make an informed choice about whether I should use that software. Homebrew is a great example. I know that it's sending telemetry to Google only because someone raised a ruckus and used social pressure to make the homebrew devs add in a reasonable amount of consent into the install and update process. Thankfully, laws are catching up with technology, and I should soon be able to rely upon simply saying "data collection not directly tied to software functionality legally requires my explicit consent, and that consent is not required to run the software".
- haecceity 6y agoI don't think you understand how telemetry works because you're comparing it to scrolljacking and such. The telemetry they're talking about is for error reporting. It answers questions like 1. Did this error condition that should not happen happen? 2. How many users did it happen for? (Who is not available for legal reasons) If you search for tracelogging in the code you'll find they're associated with debugging and errors. https://github.com/microsoft/winget-cli/blob/e997f3e394e66f2389f4f33f36c58b1c2768e975/src/AppInstallerCommonCore/Telemetry/TraceLogging.cpp https://github.com/microsoft/winget-cli/blob/e997f3e394e66f2... I don't know if you understand how difficult it is to debug programs that fail on someone else's machine. Well that's what telemetry is for.
- CJefferson 6y agoThis is a link to github, it's already open source. So, I think your wish is granted?
- falcolas 6y agoThat's the case for this particular program, however this thread of conversation is aimed at software telemetry in general.
- arcatech 6y ago> My purchase of a piece of software does not give that software provider carte blanche access to what I do with that software. Says who?
- haecceity 6y agoI bet you also want the software to work and not have bugs. Telemetry gives devs information to prioritize and debug information fix the bugs.
- cwhiz 6y agoYou can... 1. Make telemetry opt-in and ask the user to share data. This is what Apple does 2. Collect telemetry and give the user an option to share that data after a crash or bug. Many companies do this. 3. Make telemetry opt-out but be forthright with what information is sent and why. 4. Don't allow opting out of telemetry but be open and upfront with what is being collected and why. 5. Hide the fact that telemetry is being sent, hide what is being sent, and don't allow the user to opt out.
- m463 6y ago> Make telemetry opt-in and ask the user to share data. This is what Apple does You should check - apple software still contacts the mothership constantly.
- type0 6y agoBy that reasoning Enterprise edition of Windows is worse because users actually can turn the spying off
- rumanator 6y ago>>I bet you also want the software to work and not have bugs. Telemetry gives devs information to prioritize and debug information fix the bugs. You're just illustrating a single possible use among the universe of actual real world uses of telemetry, such as gathering your personal info to build up your profile to use against you as the company sees fit. As others have stated throughout this discussion, it's standard practice for over a decade to use systems that don't collect telemetry to keep systems updated and safe. It boggles the mind how some people try to claim that the only way to remain safe with Microsoft products is to be perpetually spied upon.
- ric2b 6y agoAnd yet, if anything, I see an inverse correlation between software quality and invasive telemetry. Maybe there's a correlation between invasive telemetry and not caring about your users.