4 ms·
I kind of wonder if this is the kind of stuff that mostly gets developed and tested at a desk or in a lab. One particularly troublesome problem with the Phone
by m463 7y ago
I kind of wonder if this is the kind of stuff that mostly gets developed and tested at a desk or in a lab.
One particularly troublesome problem with the Phone app is that touching just about anything accidentally initiates a call. That was hell for my mom and I'll bet your mom has it worse.
One thing I always wish the Phone app had was a "confirm" dialog when dialing a number (like what you get when you tap on a phone number external to the Phone app)
on a similar note, I know Tesla's UI is probably tested at a desk where everything is visible and stable, but in a moving car doing things like scrolling through a list of music and selecting is almost impossible.
- frereubu 7y agoYeah, my mum does get tense about that kind of stuff. Tech support calls to her are regularly interrupted by her saying things like "oh, what's happenened now?!" I was originally pretty down on skeumorphic design in aesthetic terms, but the new iOS design language is really hard to have intuitions about. When talking to mum about clicking on one of those blue "back" links at the top left in settings I really wish I could call it a "button", but it doesn't look like a button, so I just have to say "click X at the top left", whereas if I was able to say "the button that says X at the top left" it narrows down what she's looking for significantly. I really like the idea of a "confirm" button for significant taps, such as a phone call, which could be enabled in Settings.
- dwighttk 7y agoI would use that confirm button. In 10 years of owning an iPhone I’ve initiated ~10 phone calls that I intended and probably ~30 other calls.
- dublinben 7y agoHave you tried the "button shapes" option in the Display & Text Size section? It's not perfect, but it makes buttons a bit more obvious.
- frereubu 7y agoI tried that before, but unfortunately rather than showing a "button shape" it just underlines the text. That's works for things like an email address in a contact card, but not so much for the "back" links at the top left. Thanks for the suggestion though.
- AnonC 7y agoI say this with sincere belief. I hope Jony Ive’s departure from Apple results in better changes to the interface elements and interactions. While the skeuomorphic design of iOS 6 and before looked over the top in comparison to the flat designs we see now, I believe Scott Forstall had something good going on with iOS interfaces (not talking about Maps and what happened with that). Things got worse after he was fired and Jony Ive took over the UI/UX part too.
- m463 7y ago> skeumorphic design ios 7 was a real turn for the worse in that respect.
- Angostura 7y agoIt may feel very strange for someone in their late 80s, but for making calls, Siri could be the answer.
- Bud 7y agoThis is what I'd suggest, too, for sure. Just don't use the Phone app at all, if it's causing issues. My Mom, who is 75, routinely uses Siri for all kinds of stuff. She's taken to it quite naturally and it seems to work extremely well for her. If you're using a voice interface, shaky hands become irrelevant!
- dzhiurgis 7y agoIt’s almost sadistic how little languages Siri supports and how Apple restricts using other services (Google).
- jldugger 7y agoThere are usability studies done, but the average Apple employee, while older than say facebook, is not likely to overlap much on the 'shakey hands' front.