3 ms·
These discussions never seem to mention cultural soft power. Even if China were technologically superior to the US, they simply don’t have the cultural producti
by keiferski 6y ago
These discussions never seem to mention cultural soft power. Even if China were technologically superior to the US, they simply don’t have the cultural production that the US (and broadly, English-language media) has. American television and movies are known the world over, whereas I can’t name more than a handful of (non-Hong Kong) Chinese books/movies with global reach. I also don’t see Mandarin replacing English as the global default trade language. China would need to make its own NYC and Hollywood to begin to compete with this.
Why is this relevant to tech? Because I think one could argue that many tech companies are built upon this cultural capital; it’s hard to imagine YouTube being successful globally without being the source of a ton of American-made video content.
- claudeganon 6y agoTikTok would like a word.
- keiferski 6y agoI seriously question the idea of comparing TikTok to the entirety of the American film and media industry. A better comparison would be to SnapChat.
- papeda 6y agoSerious question: is it a soft power win for China if most non-Chinese users don't think of it as a Chinese product?
- claudeganon 6y agoI would say so. For me (in the US), the amount of TikTok reposts on platforms like Twitter and Instagram seems to grow by the day and I rarely, if ever, see the concern about it being a Chinese app raised.
- papeda 6y agoMaybe there are two type of soft power. The first type is where a company makes a globally popular product. The second type is where a company makes a globally popular product that is recognizably "of its country". TikTok is the first, McDonalds/Hollywood/NBA is the second?