4 ms·
Fatal accidents per 100,000 hours: GA: ~1.0 All helicopters: ~0.7 Commercial fixed wing: 0.05 (And the accidents that do occur on commercial flights are mos
by TylerE 6y ago
Fatal accidents per 100,000 hours:
GA: ~1.0
All helicopters: ~0.7
Commercial fixed wing: 0.05
(And the accidents that do occur on commercial flights are mostly small cargo planes... for major airlines that number would be more like 0.01 although it's hard to really get good numbers at that point because the numerator is so small... there are years when the US doesn't have a single fatal commercial passenger crash)
- DrScump 6y agoAll helicopters: ~0.7 And how many of those were from equipment failure, rather than pilot error? The famous helicopter crashes that come to mind (e.g. Kobe, Bill Graham) were not from mechanical failure.
- travisjungroth 6y agoWhy does it matter? Doesn't really make a difference why it happened if you're in the back.
- DrScump 6y agoIt matters with respect to the parent comment quote about helicopter travel itself being unsafe, while statistics show it's safer than fixed wing GA.
- michaelt 6y agoChainsaw-juggling is as safe as knitting if you ignore human error. Safer, in fact, as so few chainsaw jugglers die of old age while engaging in their hobby. I'm not sure anyone would say chainsaw juggling was safe, though.
- TylerE 6y agoThat's a low bar. The vast majority of helicopter operations are commercial (They're EXPENSIVE, so pleasure helicopters...don't really exist), and the accident rate is far far worse than commerical fixed wing... 20x or more.
- AdrianB1 6y agoIt matters a lot; I am flying very relaxed knowing the type the plane I fly has a very good track record of reliability and most problems happened due to pilot error. At least I know that if I respect the rules and don't do stupid things I am almost as safe as a commercial airliner and that is considered the safest means of transportation we have. And I know enough about planes not to fly a GA plane with an unknown pilot. It works for me, I have my own license, so the main criteria is the plane reliability and that is different between various models.
- griffinkelly 6y agoI was talking to a guy in my squadron whos also a rated helicopter pilot when the Kobe crash happened, and he was explaining how much easier it is to become disoriented in a helicopter because you can freely move in any direction, unlike a plane, you're always moving forward. Additionally, he was saying many helicopter pilots don't stay current in IFR flying.
- akiselev 6y ago"Amateur-built and other experimental aircraft [like fighter jets] were involved in almost 25 percent of U.S. fatal general aviation accidents over the past five years and account for an estimated five percent of total general aviation fleet hours." [1] There are a few more extenuating factors that account for a significant fraction of the rest of the fatality rate. It's just like the driving fatality rate - by eliminating drunk driving, speeding, exhaustion, texting, etc., driving becomes significantly safer than it is on paper average over the entire population. That fatality rate certainly does not represent even a mildly experienced pilot in a 172 [1] https://www.faa.gov/news/fact_sheets/news_story.cfm?newsId=21274 https://www.faa.gov/news/fact_sheets/news_story.cfm?newsId=2...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]