4 ms·
That forgiving / lack of speed thing seems critical. I read crash reports from time to time. Pilot without a lot of experience in faster planes trades up for
by duxup 7y ago
That forgiving / lack of speed thing seems critical.
I read crash reports from time to time. Pilot without a lot of experience in faster planes trades up for a faster plane and can't keep up with the situation happens time and again.
It seems like there is a sort of multi level system of pilots out there and the slower and forgiving planes keep a lot of folks safe who otherwise might be in trouble in something faster.
- bronco21016 7y agoFaster planes just require far more experience. Typically owner/operators simply do not fly enough to gain that critical mass of experience. Additionally, the fastest of aircraft, jets, typically operate with 2 crew members so the odds of a critical mistake from both pilots falling behind at the same time is drastically reduced.
- pageandrew 7y agoThere's an emerging market for fast (300kt), turbofan powered, "relatively inexpensive"(still $2m+) light/very light jets. For example, Cirrus SF50 (Vision Jet) and HondaJet. There are also some larger business jets in the Cessna Citation and Embraer Phenom line that can be used for single pilot ops. So, there's definitely an opportunity for wealthy, owner-operator pilots to fly fast aircraft that might be too much airplane for them. Turbofan aircraft do require an additional type rating (i.e. more training/qualification). Type ratings however do not expire, so one could find themselves in a situation where they're legally allowed to fly but not proficient enough to do so safely.
- duxup 7y agoHappens with charter pilots too it seems. I read a report where the pilot was trying out a turbofan that his employer was looking at buying. The guy selling the plane felt like the pilot was just not keeping up with the plane, didn't sell it to the charter company. Charter company got another plane somewhere else ( it didn't say how or where ). On a flight the pilot somehow didn't notice the autopilot disconnected, plane drifted into this long turn. Once the pilot realized something was up he grabbed the controls and pulled them hard over and snapped off the wings.
- lisper 7y agoReference? That sounds like an apocryphal story to me. It is incredibly hard to break the wings off an airplane.
- redis_mlc 7y agoJust keep pulling back in a spiral. Count to 10. Off they go.
- averros 7y agoYou will likely black out first. Small GA planes in normal category are usually designed to handle 4.6G in "down" direction without any damage to airframe. To tear wings off you'd need 6-7G. In negative direction it's smaller Gs, but it would also either disable (gravity fed) or overwhelm (pump based) fuel system resulting in loss of power. The realistic way to tear wings off small plane is to enter uncontrolled spin at altitude sufficient for gaining lots of vertical speed (and then botch recovery) or do a way-over-Vne dive.
- sokoloff 7y agoTurbojet aircraft require an annual proficiency training event that’s quite similar in scope to a check ride. https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/14/61.58 https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/14/61.58 So, while it’s technically true that the type rating does not expire, you still need annual training and certification.
- duxup 7y agoIt seems like time is the key element, the faster you go the less time you have to assess the situation before things start going wrong and things keep compounding. Extra guy, more chances of keeping on top of things, etc.
- njovin 7y agoThis and generally speaking the faster the plane the more inputs and outputs you have which makes navigating a decision tree harder. Cessna with fixed gear, one engine, no autopilot: if suddenly you find yourself in a dangerous or scary situation there’s not much you have to check to get a troubleshooting picture of the situation. Turbo twin with all the bells and whistles: not only are you traveling much faster (possibly in to a dangerous situation) but there a ton more inputs and variables to take in and a lot more things you can change to right the situation. It can be overwhelming.
- TylerE 7y agoNewer planes reverse this to an extent. Modern engines with FADEC lower pilot workload considerably. Basically - you have a single power lever, vs anywhere from about 3-5 controls on older carbureted engines.
- VBprogrammer 7y agoI'm trying to think what 5 levers you are thinking of. Obviously, throttle, prop, mixture. Carb heat is probably the 4th. The 5th is where things get a bit esoteric, perhaps manual turbo waste gate (aka second throttle)? Ah, less esoteric, probably the cowl flaps.
- noneeeed 7y agoSounds like the up-in-the-air version of (mostly) middle-age guys getting motorbikes that are just too damn powerful for their level of experience and then getting killed.