3 ms·
That would give the government no control over who pays how much in ‘taxes’. Printing money only makes money worth less, not other goods. Because of that, it
by Someone 6y ago
That would give the government no control over who pays how much in ‘taxes’.
Printing money only makes money worth less, not other goods.
Because of that, it would ‘tax’ those with more cash and fewer goods more than those with less cash and more goods. for example, that would mean it would ‘tax’ house owners less than renters.
One could argue that is fine, but in practice, poorer people cannot choose between renting and buying a house, and some would find it unfair to have those poorer people bear the burden of paying for the operation of the government.
It would also lead to inflation. That would make currencies of countries that print less or no money more attractive. So, the situation where all counties print money instead of raising taxes might be an equilibrium, but it won’t be a stable one. A country that switches to raising taxes would see its imports get cheaper and cheaper. That’s good for it’s citizens (to a limit, as it also would make exports more expensive)
- naveen99 6y ago> that would give the government no control over who pays how much in ‘taxes’. Government would still have control on who it spends money on. So it could spend more on the people it would normally tax less.
- al_chemist 6y ago> it would ‘tax’ house owners less than renters It would tax house owners less than people who had same amount of money but didn't buy house and kept money in bank. If both house owner and renter had $1000 in bank, they would lose the same.
- gremlinsinc 6y agoWouldn't a UBI w/ land value tax + VAT and no income tax possibly be a better way to control inflation, maybe ease the burden of tax-filing, and also provide a cushion for lower incomes and middle class families?