Sure, sure, that may well be. My point is that it does not work in Germany, even with a much more homogeneous and stable population that leans collectivist. I d

Sure, sure, that may well be. My point is that it does not work in Germany, even with a much more homogeneous and stable population that leans collectivist. I don't see a compelling reason why it would work in the US with a population that leans individualist, with much more pronounced social classes, much larger differences in education between those classes and stronger income inequality. Basically: if you can't get the well-behaved children to do what you ask of them, what makes you think the rowdy kids will do when you ask them?