5 ms·
The aerosapace community of "old boy firms" is very tight-knit. So tight-knit that there are people with stars on their shoulders who---even though these proces
by shadowgovt 7y ago
The aerosapace community of "old boy firms" is very tight-knit. So tight-knit that there are people with stars on their shoulders who---even though these processes are ostensibly open-bidding---will start asking questions about someone's national security clearances and loyalty to the country if one of the blessed firms doesn't get a contract. After all, if one of the "old boy firms" goes bankrupt, there goes America's capacity to construct missiles and rockets in wartime, and then where would we be?
It would be a funny legacy of this White House administration if it succeeded in breaking up the traditional aerospace cartel by appointing someone so green to a NASA executive position they actually weren't aware of the politics here and ran the contracting process as if every player were on equal footing. It'd be the first I'd ever heard of it happening in aerospace. ;)
- garmaine 7y agoThe person in question ran the National Reconnaissance Office before NASA human space flight, so he is defiantly not “green”.
- ta17711771 7y agoDefiantly, or definitely?
- colinplamondon 7y agoI'm blown away by this administration on spaceflight, in the best way possible. Space Force is a huge step forward for building capabilities in space, on the military side. On the civilian side, Bridenstine is shaping up to be the greatest Administrator in NASA history. Under his watch we're getting multiple, re-usable, private launch architectures and human spaceflight capabilities. Plus, significant infrastructure in lunar orbit, forcing the ISS budget out of LEO. All under complete American control.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoSpace Force is just shuffling the deck chairs and creating new management slots.
- colinplamondon 7y agoSpace Force has far more visibility, and an institutional need to collect more budget, spend more on personnel, and build their fiefdom. As they do that, they'll consume more and more private services, and help spur more and more industry in space. For me, that's a huge, huge win.
- CrazyStat 7y ago> Space Force is a huge step forward for building capabilities in space, on the military side. Probably in violation of international treaties, but who cares about those. > Under his watch we're getting multiple, re-usable, private launch architectures and human spaceflight capabilities. The commercial crew program was begun in 2010 under the Obama administration. Probably the only reason it still exists is nobody has mentioned that to Trump. Giving credit for a 10-year-old program to Bridenstine, who's been at NASA for two years, is utter nonsense.
- teknopaul 7y agoNoo, Trumps big on Space. Dont try to baffle Trump supporters with facts. It does not work. Trump, big on Space, fact. And Space is really important this year, because whats going on on earth is fscked up beyond all recognition.
- colinplamondon 7y agoI don't mean to take anything at all away from Obama pushing COGS, as opposed to the old Constellation strategy. That was an incredible, bold move. Besides SLS, though, it didn't move meaningful industry outside of LEO. It was an important step, but didn't fundamentally move us past the post-Apollo Space Shuttle funk. The Asteroid program was potentially interesting for getting mining going, but small in scale, with long timelines. Artemis is the first time NASA has run on aggressive, tight timelines since Apollo. They're shooting for achievable, inspiring objectives -- quickly. And this time, we'll have THREE architectures that can get any American or American ally to the surface of the moon for a price. Gateway guarantees long-term government spend in Lunar orbit, just like the ISS guaranteed long-term government spend in Earth orbit. Artemis aligns government spend towards the industrialization and militarization of space, on terms beneficial to the US.
- carapace 7y ago> building capabilities in space, on the military side That's a total failure. Absolute, complete, across-the-board failure of the human race. Just a few decades ago the militarization of space was universally acknowledged as inappropriate and this was codified in international law.
- DuskStar 7y ago> Just a few decades ago the militarization of space was universally acknowledged as inappropriate and this was codified in international law. That's a hell of an interpretation... I'd instead say that the world powers recognized that nukes in space would be destabilizing, and banned that specific thing. Space has been militarized since the 60s.
- carapace 7y agoThere are satellites for watching and communicating, but no weapons. Of course, actually there are weapons on some of the satellites but everyone pretends that there aren't to maintain stability. Publicly putting weapons in space is destabilizing, stupid to the point of evil.
- nickff 7y agoJust to back this up, the Soviets mounted at least one cannon to a space station (Salyut 3 in 1974), and tried to launch an orbital anti-satellite weapons platform (Polyus in 1987).
- pyuser583 7y agoSince the 50s.
- Fauntleroy 7y agoI love your idealism, but you're living on a planet full of humans. I don't _like_ this very much, but it's obvious that other superpowers (China) aren't going to be hemmed in by idealism, so we need to make sure that we are in a position to (at the very least) defend ourselves in space. Heck, even in the most idealistic portrayal of the future (Star Trek TNG) there's plenty of war in space.
- evilduck 7y agoAren't NASA's budget and their subsequent aerospace contracts mere drops in the ocean compared to the DoD budget and their contracts? It seems like a PR and politics problem more than a real risk of NASA bankrupting Boeing.
- BinaryAsteroid 7y agoWhile this is true when considering the total sum of the DoD budget, I think it would be more fair to compare the DoD's R&D budget -- which stood at something like $60B vs. NASA's $21B total... which really makes you wonder.. Anyway, along with people with stars on their shoulders, you can also piss off a congress-person who has a large NASA facility in their district..
- nickik 7y agoThe exact opposite is true. Bridenstine is/was a politicians and Loverro had a lot of experience and had political positions before. He ran military and spy space programs.