3 ms·
I know this is a sci-fi scenario, but: don't overpopulation problems evaporate once space travel and colonization really kick off? In fact, at that point, it wo
by keiferski 6y ago
I know this is a sci-fi scenario, but: don't overpopulation problems evaporate once space travel and colonization really kick off? In fact, at that point, it would seem that more people = better, at least if 'explore the universe' is something you think civilization should do.
This scenario seems doable/likely within a few hundred years. Less if space travel becomes more than a niche thing.
- bagacrap 6y agoUnfortunately it seems the Earth is also going to be uninhabitable "within a few hundred years".
- orev 6y agoSpace travel and colonization is so far off from a realistic option that you might as well be talking about Captain Marvel swooping in and saving the planet. The physics simply don’t allow it to happen (short of some truly major breakthrough like warp drive/time travel). And we don’t have hundreds or thousands of years to wait for things like that — the current trends point to a few decades at best to solve these problems. Also, colonization creates more people. The current ones stay where they are, while only a few adventurers move to the new place, and then have kids there. Most people are not going to give up a lifetime’s worth of building a life somewhere, at least not in the numbers needed to impact total population.
- keiferski 6y agoI don't know, that seems a bit pessimistic. Right now, space travel is a tiny fraction of global economic activity. What if that increased 10x, 100x, or 1,000x? Submarines and self-contained vessels might be a good metaphor/approach, as compared to a full-blown colony. It doesn't seem implausible that we could have millions of self-contained spaceships, each carrying hundreds of people, within ~200 years, assuming that serious percentages of GDP are put toward it.
- ben_w 6y agoWe could, but hundreds of millions is a small fraction of our population and 200 years is too long if it’s an important part of the solution. Also, cislunar space is much easier than colonising the planets, which is in turn orders of magnitude easier than colonising other star systems — even if you can find enough people to do it, which is hard because why would Joe or Jane Average want to go to a deep space colony where ping-time is measured in years at best, or dozens of geological epochs at worst?
- ben_w 6y agoSpace is big. Really big. It’s such a long way to the nearest star to Sol that I expect a billion people living in a floating Pacific seastead community before I the first hundred thousand reach the stars. Unfortunately, once we do have proper cheap space access with e.g. a launch loop, the exponential nature of growth means it only takes 50 generations of 4-child families to go up each step along the Kardeshev scale. After type II, population growth is limited by the speed of light.
- yardie 6y agoIn the longterm it's theoretically possibly, in the short term (in human lifetimes) we'll die on this planet trying to make it happen elsewhere. To colonize another planet will take a lots of terraforming. Terraforming takes tons of energy in manufacturing, transportation, and sustainability. Those resources will have to be mined from earth, transported to another planet, and installed there until a colony is sustainable. A bit of history. The American Revolution was initiated by the Stamp Act. The Stamp Act was initiated because the UK government treasury was being drained by trying to sustain a distant colony. They assumed, wrongly, the colonists would help pay for the ships, army, and resources they were being subsidized. The French revolution began out of King Louis XVI draining the French treasury to support the American revolution. When famine hit and he didn't have the resources to feed his people, CHOP! So to get a space based colony running you're going to need to convince a whole lot of people that things are going to suck for a while but the payoff is generations away. I don't see that happening in todays climate. I think the series The Expanse gets space colonization mostly right. The Belters have it hard because space. Terrans have it hard because Earth is dying.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoLet's suppose that space travel (interstellar, or just interplanetary?) kicks off. Let's suppose that we colonize Mars, or even Alpha Centauri. Well, there's a big difference between moving a thousand colonists to Mars, and moving a billion people to Mars. (What's the carrying capacity for Mars?) Even more so with Alpha Centauri. I see exactly zero chance that, within a few hundred years, there will be enough space travel to move enough people off of Earth to significantly change the population of Earth.
- asdff 6y agoIt depends on how colonization actually works out. If all materials would have to be delivered from earth, no way in hell. The New World would have never took off if all the wood needed for building the village had to be imported from Spain.