3 ms·
I'm also a network/server admin. I don't see things as you do. Specialised protocols are better than generalised ones because they have understandable failure
by dijit 7y ago
I'm also a network/server admin.
I don't see things as you do. Specialised protocols are better than generalised ones because they have understandable failure modes.
If DNS goes down, name resolution fails. But if DoH goes down, it could still be DNS, it could be TLS Suites, it could be incorrect headers, it could be mishandling of the proxy (or the proxy forwarding garbage), it could be anything.
that's why we consider DNS to be Layer 6 and not Layer 7, as things on Layer 7 may depend on it.
- iso1631 7y agoSo DNS is easier to debug? So are many protocols. It doesn't mean we should still be using http, rlogin, or snmpv1. There are significant benefits to the end user of DoH in bypassing malicious networks. It's out there, it's not going away. I'd like it to integrate well in a situation where I am the user, sysadmin and netadmin.
- dijit 7y agorlogin -> ssh. unless you're saying we should replace SSH with HTTP. And yes, DNS is easier to debug than HTTP if HTTP depends on HTTP.
- syshum 7y agoWell at this rate HTTP will simply eat all other things
- iso1631 7y agoThe problem is that DoT has almost all the drawbacks of DNS from ability to block (and thus fall back to non-TLS dns which can be manipulated), and almost all the drawbacks of DoH (harder to debug). It's the worst of both worlds.