3 ms·
> So I go out and find an introductory tutorial, which is without fail written with exactly the sort of smug self-satisfaction that this thread is written. And
by naasking 6y ago
> So I go out and find an introductory tutorial, which is without fail written with exactly the sort of smug self-satisfaction that this thread is written. And I immediately lose interest.
I think reading that tone into a tutorial, or from this thread, says more about you than the community.
And even if they were smug, consider the possibility that maybe they have good reason. Would you never buy a Tesla because Elon Musk smugly claims his cars are the best on the market?
> I'll never know, because I'd rather struggle for a lifetime through poorly-implemented languages than have to turn every time I have a problem to a community completely unable to process the idea that they might be wrong.
Cut off your hand to spite your face? Your choice of course, but from my experience as a non-Haskeller, the community is perfectly welcoming and willing to explain details to beginners.
Also, if the Haskell "community" never thought they were wrong, they would never disagree. That's clearly not the case if you perused any mailing list or thread.
- wyattpeak 6y agoTFA: > which really should have implemented a well-known concept (Monoid, Monad, Alternative, whatever), but they fell short because they (probably) didn't know the concept If that's not smug self-satisfaction, I don't know what is. No consideration that there were reasons they implemented their system in a different way. Suggestion that it was done due to ill-education on their part. I reread it carefully after your accusation. I don't want to too readily assume the worst in people. I am extremely comfortable with the accusation I laid on that thread. But to your other point, I don't consider the possibility that they have good reason for their smugness. I don't find it implausible (as I said, albeit sarcastically), I just find smugness entirely orthogonal to correctness. There are brilliant smug people, but flat-earthers are also among the more smug people I've encountered. If I lived in a world with only ten languages, I might agree I was punishing myself more than them. But I will never learn every language, tool, technique or skill I want to, so why would I ever start here?
- naasking 6y ago> If that's not smug self-satisfaction, I don't know what is. No consideration that there were reasons they implemented their system in a different way. Of course there was consideration. The history surrounding this is well documented. People familiar with the relevant concepts raised the problems with the JS Promise API early on, but were dismissed. Which is also beside the point, because generalizing from N=1 is silly. If I'm being generous, you pointed out one smug Haskeller, where you claimed that the entire community was smug. > If I lived in a world with only ten languages, I might agree I was punishing myself more than them. But I will never learn every language, tool, technique or skill I want to, so why would I ever start here? Allow me to rephrase with an analogy to illustrate: I can easily solve 90% of my problems perfectly well with just integers, reals and complex numbers, so why would I ever learn general vector or matrix math? Certainly that's your perogative, but I hope you'll agree that you're ignoring a powerful tool that would subsume all of your previous understanding of these abstractions, and which would let you solve those same problems, and more, better.