3 ms·
> One could argue that it's not that the value of a dollar varies by location, but that the value of a quarter pounder varies by location. And I think that migh
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> One could argue that it's not that the value of a dollar varies by location, but that the value of a quarter pounder varies by location. And I think that might be a more practical perspective, since a variable-value dollar would present an easy arbitrage opportunity, whereas buying quarter pounders in Manhattan and reselling them in Peoria is a scheme that would run afoul of some technical challenges.
You could make that argument, but it wouldn't be a very good argument, since the value of everything is systematically higher (measured in dollars) in Manhattan than in Peoria. The obvious model is that the value of the dollar is lower in Manhattan. (Also, you seem to have mixed up where you would be buying the hamburgers and where you'd be selling them.)
- leetcrew 7y agothis might seem obvious, but it doesn't really describe the situation well. things are expensive in manhattan because it is expensive to live in/around manhattan. even the lowly mcdonalds employee gets paid about twice as much to work in manhattan as in peoria. if you buy something that doesn't require local storage/labor, it will cost the same as it does in the rest of the country.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> things are expensive in manhattan because it is expensive to live in/around manhattan. even the lowly mcdonalds employee gets paid about twice as much to work in manhattan as in peoria. All of this supports the idea that the value of a dollar is lower in Manhattan than elsewhere. Indeed, it doesn't just support the idea; it is a restatement of it.
- leetcrew 7y agoonly if you ignore why it's more expensive to live in NYC. it's more expensive because it's more desirable to live in NYC than Peoria. waterfront property is also more expensive than similar inland properties. the water doesn't locally inflate the dollar; it's a feature that people pay extra for. if you accept that the real value of a dollar is less in NYC, you also have to accept weird consequences like a CPU from amazon is worth less there as well.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ebg13 7y ago> waterfront property is also more expensive than similar inland properties. That explains _property_, not McDonalds Quarter Pounders which are exactly the same everywhere.
- leetcrew 7y agoit's another example of the same phenomenon. a mcdonald's quarter pounder is not the same everywhere. the sandwich itself is the same, but the location is an important (and sometimes expensive) part of the whole package. how much would you pay for a big mac that happens to be located a hundred miles away from you?
- ebg13 7y ago> how much would you pay for a big mac that happens to be located a hundred miles away from you? You just showed that proximity to the buyer matters, not location, because _delivery_ is an additional cost in both money and time. If you want an apt comparison, you need to not bundle unrelated expenses. Whichever McDonalds I'm at, proximity to me is the same at time of purchasing identical Quarter Pounders, and the price is not.
- leetcrew 7y agowe seem to be talking past each other, but I'm curious to see exactly where our positions diverge. I think you already agreed that waterfront property is more valuable in real terms than a similar inland property because being close to the water is a desirable feature to some people. do you also agree that a retail space in NYC is more valuable than a similar space in peoria, in the same real sense, with the vast social and business network of NYC being the value add? if you agree that the real value of property in NYC is higher (due to proximity to lots of other desirable stuff), then you should agree that it makes sense that property commands a higher rent here. because the rent is higher, so too is the cost of labor and storage. if you follow the chain of reasoning thus far, you should agree that the real value of a quarter pounder in NYC is simply higher due to the higher input costs. I don't think there is an absolute "correct" answer here. we are arguing for competing models, and a model is only good insofar as it explains/predicts reality. if I squint hard enough, I can see why yours might make sense. but it seems to raise a lot more questions than answers. if a dollar in NYC is truly worth less than a dollar in peoria, why is this only reflected in the price of local goods and services (ie, stuff where local rent is a major input)? why does stuff from amazon have the same nominal cost everywhere in the US? it seems much simpler to just accept that NYC property has a higher real value and let everything else follow from that.
- mumblemumble 7y agoI wouldn't focus too much on just counting the number of variables. Oftentimes the more parsimonious explanation is the one that emerges from a simple principle being applied to a lot of moving parts. In this case, I would say that the perspective where it's the value of a dollar that varies is not particularly parsimonious, because it leads to a strange set of implications that could only be resolved by adding epicycles to the theory. For example, if you favor the perspective where it's the value of the dollar that varies between New York and Peoria, then you also need to account for why the dollar/euro exchange rate does not tend to vary between the two. It would be peculiar indeed if it were that the euro's value also varied by location, but just happened to vary in lockstep with the dollar. (I realize this is the scenario that's happening in TFA, but that's kind of exactly what the TFA is getting at: the rial is on the verge of forking into two different currencies.) You would also have to account for why the relative nominal prices of goods don't stay constant from location to location. Suppose that a quarter pounder costs $2 and a tube of toothpaste costs $4 in NYC. If it's the dollar value that changes, then one should be able to assume that a $1 quarter pounder in Peoria implies that toothpaste costs $2 in Peoria. My appetite for air travel right now doesn't permit me to test this myself, but I suspect that you will find that this is not actually the case.