3 ms·
>Think about that for a second. The German government confers more privacy rights on foreigners with no connection to their country whatsoever than the American
by Barrin92 7y ago
>Think about that for a second. The German government confers more privacy rights on foreigners with no connection to their country whatsoever than the American government is even willing to extend to citizens.
And being German I'm proud of it. It's hard to make any rational case for why these rights which we take to be fundamental and vitally important ought to end at our borders.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThe rational case is the very job and purpose of foreign intelligence services. There are right and laws that should apply to all, but realistically there is also the national interest, "Raison d'Etat". There obviously has to be a balance but if rights and laws are absolute and may never be breached or ignored then foreign intelligence services simply cease to exist, and it is highly naive to think that this would be fine.
- dane-pgp 7y agoIs your position not analogous to saying "The point of an army is to kill people, therefore if Germany forbids its army from killing unarmed civilians then it might as well not have an army at all"? I don't believe you have such a view about armies, and I don't think that the German ruling is in danger of making their foreign intelligence services inoperable.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoMy position is clearly not what you suggest because we're discussing activities than fall within what foreign intelligence services do whereas this is clearly not the case in your contrived example.
- close04 7y agoIf you're a regular citizen with no reason for suspicion, or just a journalist and still get spied on "just in case" then it's a violation of those rights. The constitution is there to ensure that people are considered an enemies that haven't been caught yet. Unless you have a concrete reason to suspect spying is needed, then it's not needed. And "may be a criminal therefore must be a criminal" is not such a reason. It's just like the Police shouldn't treat people like criminals who haven't given themselves away and search their cars and houses arbitrarily. The constitution should be there to actually defend those rights, not just so people have something to pound their chests about every day while being undermined by all kinds of laws and exceptions, making it selectively worthless.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThe discussion is not about citizens. It's very costly to do blanket monitoring so in practice it's just keywords matching or they do target suspicious people for more in depth analysis. I am quite comfortable with my country's intelligence services doing blanket keywords monitoring, or more, on as many communications as they can get their hands on coming from specific countries or geographical areas. "Don't hate the player, hate the game" as the saying goes.
- close04 7y ago> The discussion is not about citizens. It is about any person that would be caught in the wide spying net despite not being under any reasonable suspicion whatsoever. Blanket monitoring just means "more than one's warranted interest targets". If there are reasons for suspicion and they justify spying it will still happen. > I am quite comfortable Should the constitution enshrine the right to "the lowest thing one person is quite comfortable with"? Yes, plenty of people are quite comfortable taking a lot of crap as long as they can still brag about their rights and their constitution. Others would rather see those rights enforced. Do you want your constitution to protect more than your bragging rights? Than perhaps you should defend it an not just "be comfortable" with one more violation.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoIf only we all lived in the world you seem to live in!
- Barrin92 7y agoWhat the German court argued wasn't that intelligence services cannot exist, it was that blanket surveillance of foreign individuals is not legitimate, including for example journalists which we grant protection in particular. What our court is arguing is that these rights are cosmopolitan in nature, not that they're unlimited. What I think is irrational is that the German border (or anyone's border) delineates those rights. To say this surveillance is justified because the services and the nation state exists is circular. The question is why we let tribalism determine whose rights we defend in the first place.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoWhat is legitimate depends on the specific circumstances and is ultimately a political decision by the government. Foreign intelligence services often deal with nasty stuff all the way to toppling foreign governments and targeted assassinations, and that should be fully allowed. In terms of foreign intelligence I do not see why foreign journalists or lawyers should be afforded any special protection. Border do delineate rights. At the very least they delineate areas of 'concern'. The German government's job is to look after Germany and its citizens and residents. You can argue against nation states but I think that is highly idealistic. In any case threats abroad are not only coming from foreign governments, very far from it. Basically, IMHO foreign intelligence services should not be restricted in what they can do, rather they should only be required to get the right level of approval depending on how serious the action is. I believe that this is already the case (though I understand that German services may be more restricted than others) and that it will continue to be the case, hence why I don't think this decision will change things much.